There's plenty of examples of Swindon fans being horrendously wrong in evaluating a player / manager.

Who's most likely to have been involved from our side? Harry? Ollie? (Clarke, not Holloway)

The circle of life continues...

Some of our fans think that Holloway is Premiership level  manager

Sinclairs entire game was built on pace though right? Holloway was awful saying he wanted a forward/winger that could get in behind the defence to compliment what he has. I struggle to see that Sinclair meets that criteria at his age. But lets see i guess.

I have to say I have Gas fans in a special category all of their own, Barton certainly didn't help their cause.

You have to bear in mind that Rovers fans are a special type of wierd though.

They thought Holloway was a shit manager and old fashioned and not at all suited to the modern game, they suggested Ollie Clarkes legs had gone totally when we signed him from Mansfield, Nichols was shit, back in the late 80s I was told by some of their fans that Chalkie White was rubbish and would never score many goals.

He did play 45 games across last season, averaging 45.8 minutes per game. So the legs aren’t completely gone, you either get a Grant Hall or a Matty Taylor.

Not sure if Sinclair would be in the same category, but I think we’d have happily signed McGoldrick even if he couldn’t pass tge running test

https://www.thesun.co.uk/sport/35835359/efl-charged-fa-breaching-betting-rules-macari/

Lou Macari’s grandson (Notts County defender) charged by the FA for breaching betting rules.