The Ex Swindon Town Player Where Are They Now Thread

[DV]

That McKirdy headline reads bad but when you read the full quote, it isn't nearly. Basically said its a short career, you have to get on with ambitions and he assumed the club would want to cash in also (which was true).

On Payne though, if we were the middle offer and Charlton was the lowest and you're moving for family reasons, surely you'd go with Crawley the highest offer? Its not exactly far.

Sounds like bollocks to me. At least with McKirdy he is honest, even if it comes across harsh.

Where as I read his comments as basically saying

‘I signed for Swindon on the cheap because no one wanted me but the minute I started playing well I knew I was wanted to leave’

[tans]

Yeah thats how i read it too

[Nemo]

On Payne though, if we were the middle offer and Charlton was the lowest and you're moving for family reasons, surely you'd go with Crawley the highest offer? Its not exactly far.

I wouldn't be surprised if a good agent suggested that the Crawley offer might be a bit "too good to be true" - wouldn't be the first club to have new ownership pumping money in, sign players on big contracts and then rather struggle to honour them once the financial realities changed. Add that to simply being a much bigger club in a higher division, and I think he pretty clearly made the right choice, as much as we'd like to have retained him.

[Ƭ̵̬̊: The Artist Formerly Known as CWIG]

Where as I read his comments as basically saying

‘I signed for Swindon on the cheap because no one wanted me but the minute I started playing well I knew I was wanted to leave’

I mean, he literally said "No one else wanted me, it was lucky Swindon were fucked so I could come here" while he was here on a podcast.

I don't blame him for having ambitions. The money factor, his old contract probably was shit as we couldn't offer much under the embargo but sounds like we didn't try too hard to keep him either.

[Ƭ̵̬̊: The Artist Formerly Known as CWIG]

I wouldn't be surprised if a good agent suggested that the Crawley offer might be a bit "too good to be true" - wouldn't be the first club to have new ownership pumping money in, sign players on big contracts and then rather struggle to honour them once the financial realities changed. Add that to simply being a much bigger club in a higher division, and I think he pretty clearly made the right choice, as much as we'd like to have retained him.

Yeah size of club and division probably made more of a factor though really. Its just surprising he didn't see that as its usually something fans like to hear.

[Batch]

Alex Henshall -> Melksham

Not taking the piss, he had to take the City chance I suppose. Shame it didn't quite work out. Whether he would have been better staying we'll never know.

[Jimmy Quinn]

He's still only 28 has he dropped out of the football league too early or is he injury prone🤔

[horlock07]

Alex Henshaw -> Melksham

Not taking the piss, he had to take the City chance I suppose. Shame it didn't quite work out. Whether he would have been better staying we'll never know.

Henshall its Henshall 

I imagine that Louis Thompson would be having  awry smile about this.

[Batch]

Henshall its Henshall 

It is indeed. Corrected

[horlock07]

He's still only 28 has he dropped out of the football league too early or is he injury prone🤔

This seems to suggest a trend of trial, signing, release at the end of the season? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Henshall

[Jimmy Quinn]

This seems to suggest a trend of trial, signing, release at the end of the season? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alex_Henshall

Cheers H for the link. It's baffling that a player with so much talent and seemingly the right attitude never really made it.

[4D]

https://therealefl.co.uk/2022/12/21/the-chance-of-me-staying-was-1-harry-mckirdy-talks-leaving-swindon-town-to-join-hibs-in-exclusive-interview/

Hmmm,  played in 8 games for Hibs, 234 minutes and zero goals. Wonder where he will be come January? 

[DMC]

He's still only 28 has he dropped out of the football league too early or is he injury prone🤔

Never really played league football to be fair. be amazed if he has started over 20 games in his career

[Jimmy Quinn]

Never really played league football to be fair. be amazed if he has started over 20 games in his career

One of the reasons why it's not a good idea going to a massive club at such a young age. Maybe get established in the lower leagues and move on once you've proved yourself like Austin & Twine did. Amongst others Rideout, Horlock & Simpson are other good examples.

[ron dodgers]

It probably set him up for the rest of his life