Players lose their way. Not writing him off before he has signed and kicked a ball.
But it's always interesting to read fans views
100000% this.
No need to write any player off before they have even agreed a deal to sign for us, if indeed it is him and it happens.
MacDonald wasnt rated by Rotherham fans when he signed and he did ok (IMO) for us2 before the issues off the pitch.
Hes big, decent in the air, he loves to score goals with his head (averages 4 goals a season) and has experience at Peterborough, Hull, Mansfield and Wycombe with 400 games played.
I say if it is him at least give him a chance.