See the point but in both of those examples, I'd also be fairly alarmed if the airline or hospital allowed enthusiastic amateurs to stand in as co-pilot or anaesthetist as per the radio co-commentary.
FWIW, I thought the commentary was fine last night if a little flat, but I suspect that's more due to the game than the commentator. But I still prefer Vic. And I still prefer Ed over any of them
I wasn't really refering to the radio commentary, I didn't even hear it, but just refuting the argument that "those that can't do better can't criticise" which as FB pointed out is a bag of shite.