McGurk by a country mile for me.
McGurk was absent for longer periods, but when involved, scored and/or set up chances.
I think thats harsh on McGurk, I know you arent his biggest fan, flair players can't be used fully all the time, they drift in and out of games, but when they do things it shows you why they are there. McGurk scored one, had 1 assist and 2 shots that were dangerous. I don't think he could have done much more.
Hes not a defender so dont ask him to track back as its not his game, did Payne or for that matter Bobby Barnes, Mark Walters or even Don Rodgers track back and make tackles in games? no of course they didn't as thats not their game. (no I am not directly comparing his quality to them, yet)
Play him and play to his strengths and he will get better and better IMO. The only true creatve player at the club, even Ollie says similar.