I can't believe it'll actually be this clear cut. I genuinely couldn't/wouldn't pick one player over a group of 5 or 6. It almost seems unfair to single out one player when so many would be worthy winners. I voted for Cadds though, as he seems a bit of an unsung hero, despite being one of our best and most consistent performers.
Ahhh but what with the recent 'goings on' with some of the players, the likes of Flint, Ferry etc now don't seem 'fit' to be Player of the Season. I'm not saying that's wrong btw, that's just my (most likely dumb) take on it!
Saying that, Ferry, despite patrolling the centre of the park very well, hasn't done anything that's been particularly eye-catching of late, and Flint's either been injured or overshadowed by Macca and in some respects, Devera, who I feel has been great at either RB or CB.
A few weeks back, people were, as you say, struggling to pick a player out of at least 5 of the current squad.
I went for Caddis anyway. Macca has been immense, and comes in at a close 2nd, but the absence of Cap'n Caddis has been noticable, as others have said.
I thought Ritchie would have had a few votes by now, I must admit. I'm sure he'll come in 3rd. He deserves a top 3 finish, if you like.