David Byrne for Manager?

[pumbaa]

I feel like I keep repeating myself time and again. In my opinion (and yes, its an opinion), David Byrne is not the man who matches the criteria for Fitton's three year vision of Championship consolidation.

He is doing a solid caretaker role right now, with some good results and performances, and some poor results and performances.

Could we afford to take a risk on him to the end of the season? Ideally not, but if Fitton can't get his man, then so be it.

And anyone thinking we're safe from relegation (as I'm sure I read above), well you've lost the plot big time there.....

[Arriba]

if he was to get the job i reckon he'd have got it by now.fittons deffo trying elsewhere(actually i think he is)
if it falls through then who knows?

[DV]

byrne knows his stuff.that is not in question imo.what is in question is.is he the best man for the job?

no Mourinho is....

and i'd love it if he was our boss.imagine it.the mind boggles
happy new year by the way dv.

happy new year you grumpy bastard.

like to see you try and kick me  

[Arriba]

byrne knows his stuff.that is not in question imo.what is in question is.is he the best man for the job?

no Mourinho is....

and i'd love it if he was our boss.imagine it.the mind boggles
happy new year by the way dv.

happy new year you grumpy bastard.

like to see you try and kick me  

got no pace anymore,but class is permanant.your lot only get out of their half when they kick off anyway.

[DV]

thats not true....


....sometimes the other team pass it back to their defenders.

Think the teams pulling out the league because its beyond a joke now. Not worth it when you struggle to get 11 'bodies' each week, let alone actual players

[DV]

...also, we kick off alot  

[sonic youth]

byrne knows his stuff.that is not in question imo.what is in question is.is he the best man for the job?

he knows how to coach a group of players, yes.

he doesn't know how to be a football manager.

maybe?maybe not?
its not a cut and dried issue is it?

mate, i just wrote a long-winded post explaining my thoughts fully - if you can't be bothered reading that then fair enough but don't try and pick an argument by stating the obvious and asking rhetorical questions.

i read it sonic.and i aint picking fuck all, i'm giving an opinion and asking questions.nothing more.just because my opinion differs, dont come the high and mighty.are you now the judge and jury on everything?
and what makes you right?how do you know he doesn't know how to be a manager?you have an opinion on it but it doesn't necesarily make it right.you've given your take on byrne above so we all must pander to the great sonic youth eh?and not say anything different to the high and mighty one?
unless byrne is given the job we wont know will we?

when have i ever said that my opinion is worth more than anyone elses? i certainly don't think that, fuck knows why you do.

i thought you were being deliberately facetious and i couldn't be bothered playing along.

anyway, as i said - he's got plenty of coaching experience, has he ever been a football manager for a significant period of time? i wouldn't even suggest he's been terribly impressive at the caretaker job he's been doing, he's made some fundamental mistakes and foolish errors - both of which are part of a steep learning curve but why should we give him the benefit of time, money and support when he's shown little to warrant that?

[DV]

Plus to add to Sonics point, we all still have nightmares of Iffy Onoura, Aaron Brown and Trevor fucking Benjamin!!!

[sonic youth]

i'm actually a little bit insulted and upset that anyone would think i'm trying to be "high and mighty" or that my opinion is more worthwhile than others. half the time i talk utter shit but i at least make the effort to back that shit up with some logic and/or reason!

i'll go have a little cry and watch the cricket, you fucking bully.

[herthab]

Byrne done a reasonable job for us since Sturrock left (Thank fuck we didn't have to rely solely on Ady again) and we haven't dropped like a stone towards the relegation zone.

If it was before Fitton, I'd say he deserves a chance to prove himself, but it's not. Harsh I know....................

[@MacPhlea]

Adi Whitbread was sat behind me who I believe was closely linked to a certain Martin Allan at Leicester... :shock:

[Arriba]

i'm actually a little bit insulted and upset that anyone would think i'm trying to be "high and mighty" or that my opinion is more worthwhile than others. half the time i talk utter shit but i at least make the effort to back that shit up with some logic and/or reason!

i'll go have a little cry and watch the cricket, you fucking bully.

likewise i was pissed off that you thought i was looking for an arguement.i cannot see how you came to that conclusion?
i wasn't even disagreeing with you, just raising questions.you then made a wild and inaccurate assumption and i bit

[fatbury]

I believe that Byrne is learning as a manager as well .. something I never mentioned before

YES we had some bad results early on .. but he is a rookie - but sometimes rookies become top bosses ... what about that bloke at Scunthorpe?

[Colin Todd]

fickle bastards.

An experienced new manager please. Byrne back to the yoofs.

[sonic youth]

Adi Whitbread was sat behind me who I believe was closely linked to a certain Martin Allan at Leicester... :shock:

he was also assistant to allen at Franchise