Swindon's Worst Ever Manager

[Crozzer]

I think this needs a poll, candidates are as follows:

Dave MacKay

Dave MacKay

Dave MacKay

[herthab]

Going purely on results, Ady Williams was a bit of a let down!

[Batch]

Since I've been watching : Colin T*dd was a prize cunt. At least Wise left us with sum sort of team when he did it. I mean Kim Heiselberg - what the fuck kind of pro footballer was he.

[Give us an S]

Andy King

[OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR]

Can't comment on Dave MacKay (Far too young  :shock: ) From what I have seen, has to be Colin Todd.

[Panda Paws]

Jimmy Quinn P 85 .. W 19 .. L 45 .. D21

That was a pretty depressing period that sticks in my mind!!!

[Panda Paws]

Dave Mackay's record, FWIW, was ...

P60 .. W18 .. L24 .. D18

[Bushey Boy]

Steve McMahon for being a total wanker

[Tails]

At least McMahon took us up though, and briefly took us to the top of the first division.

If it wasn't for us being a total cripple financially we'd have gone up that season IMO.

He was a cunt though.

[sonic youth]

it's been done.

[yeo]

Hmm since Ive been going Ive these to pick from..

1984-1989
 Lou MACARI
 285 138 67 80 449 340 60%

1989-1991
 Ossie ARDILES
 106 40 33 33 163 140 53%

1991-1993
 Glenn HODDLE
 120 51 32 37 202 162 56%

1993-1994
 John GORMAN
 72 15 20 37 90 148 35%

1994-1998
 Steve MCMAHON
 204 75 49 80 245 277 49%

1998-2000
 Jimmy QUINN
 85 19 21 45 84 141 35%

2000
 Colin TODD
 18 4 6 8 16 29 39%

2000-2001
 Andy KING
 36 12 10 14 43 43 47%

2001
 Roy EVANS
 26 10 6 10 30 35 50%

2001-2005
 Andy KING
 193 71 48 74 265 263 49%

2005-2006
 Iffy ONUORA
 40 10 15 15 40 56 44%

May-Oct 2006
 Dennis WISE
 17 9 5 3 24 14 68%

Nov 2006 - present
 Paul STURROCK
 32 18 6 8 40 27 66%

So according to the success % the worst is Gorman or Quinn.

In all honesty I didnt go during the Premiership but Gorman never had a hope in hell so his percentage for that season shouldnt really count.
Quinn,Iffy and certainly in his second spell Kingy were in impossible situations so kingys percentage prooves he was ace.
So i'll plump for Todd because what he left  was by and large a complete load of wank.

[yeo]

Who cares if its been done if we are following that rule then every fucking thread would be locked.

[sonic youth]

because it was me who did it before.

[yeo]

But I ade the effort to answer a football post seconds before you locked it.

[sonic youth]

that'll teach you