Ratings vs Palace

[reeves4england]

We don't seem to have thee threads any more......so here is one!

P Smith 7 Made some good saves and always looked confident coming for crosses. Just the one poor kick
J Smith 7 Linked up with the midfield well and also got forward well to put in crosses
Ifil 6 Defended very well and ade some good challenges but resorted to hoofs for a while
Williams 7 Was always in control, breathed confidence in the defence and told the ref when he was wrong!
Vincent 6 Occasionally let their winger get at him but generally good
Shakes 7 Showed his pace today and took on the opposition a lot more than usual, a couple of okay crosses but also linked up with J Smith well
Pook 6 Not a bad performance, he just went missing at times which allowed their midfield to press on too easily
Timlin 8 All there, ball control, passing, awarenes....MOTM
Boob 7 Pacey, direct and part of some good passing movements. Looked dangerous
Roberts 7 Harshly criticised as he won the ball, pressured defenders, held the ball up,won corners and throw ins, put good balls into the bo and we almost scored from two of his corners
Peacock 7 Won headers despite being fouled constantly, as usual! Held it up well and put the defence under a lot of pressure!

Town fans 9 Loads of us and we sang our hearts out!

Palace fans 5 Championship? You're having a laugh!

Referee 6 Not a bad game....gave the throw in when it was blatantly a corner but you've gotta blame the (female) assistant for that one!

[herthab]

Can't be arsed to go through the whole of your ratings, but Ifil gets the same rating as Pook, while Roberts gets the same as Zaboub?

Behave........

[Frigby Daser]

Couldn't make it today - gutted. One thing seems fairly unanimous - Timlin's class. We've between now and the end of the season to convince him to sign up. We need a song for him

Fulham will sell - he's 23 and not many 23 years olds break into Premiership teams having come through the youth system.

SIGN HIM UP

[reeves4england]

Can't be arsed to go through the whole of your ratings, but Ifil gets the same rating as Pook, while Roberts gets the same as Zaboub?

Behave........

Fair enough to me. Okay maybe Boob should get 7.5 then, but Roberts played well. Couldn't believe how much the Town fans got on his back when he was winning battles against two defenders.

And Pook was okay today, whereas Ifil wasn't passing well

[Bogus Dave]

Couldn't make it today - gutted. One thing seems fairly unanimous - Timlin's class. We've between now and the end of the season to convince him to sign up. We need a song for him

Fulham will sell - he's 23 and not many 23 years olds break into Premiership teams having come through the youth system.

SIGN HIM UP

thats a shit song

[red macca]

Can't be arsed to go through the whole of your ratings, but Ifil gets the same rating as Pook, while Roberts gets the same as Zaboub?

Behave........

Fair enough to me. Okay maybe Boob should get 7.5 then, but Roberts played well. Couldn't believe how much the Town fans got on his back when he was winning battles against two defenders.

And Pook was okay today, whereas Ifil wasn't passing well

if your marking him on that basis then surely he should get a 6 every week

[Fred Elliot]

Couldn't make it today - gutted. One thing seems fairly unanimous - Timlin's class. We've between now and the end of the season to convince him to sign up. We need a song for him

Fulham will sell - he's 23 and not many 23 years olds break into Premiership teams having come through the youth system.

SIGN HIM UP

Timlin IS class

I agree Moonie

I dont think we could table an acceptable offer IMO

He is soooo not a league 2................(league 1 next year) player

I am thankful that he is here 'til the end of this season and will help get us promoted.

I think he will then go to a Chamionship club

I hope I am wrong, but I have just got a feeling

[herthab]

Can't be arsed to go through the whole of your ratings, but Ifil gets the same rating as Pook, while Roberts gets the same as Zaboub?

Behave........

Fair enough to me. Okay maybe Boob should get 7.5 then, but Roberts played well. Couldn't believe how much the Town fans got on his back when he was winning battles against two defenders.

And Pook was okay today, whereas Ifil wasn't passing well

Ifils main role is to defend and I thought he did very well against higher opposition.

Roberts main role when playing out wide is to put in quality crosses, which he didn't do. His shooting today was also poor.

Timlin was my motm, everything good from midfield came through him.

[dogs]

Roberts was poor today. He had numerous chances to run into space but just held back, his touch was also as woeful as ever. Add that to being a greedy sod and clearly no eye for goal, can we please not offer him a new contract.

[Fred Elliot]

Didnt see you there Dogs !

Where were you stood ?

[lebowski]

Referee 6 Not a bad game....gave the throw in when it was blatantly a corner but you've gotta blame the (female) assistant for that one!

that was amy rayner (mike newell's mate)...

[rudeboydreas]

Roberts is not a team player. Skinning the keeper then skying it with 2 players in the area had me fuming. I think I've had enough of Roberts now.

[Sussex]

I thought we were good.

[adje]

Smith 8-no chance with either goal,he is now unofficially better than Rhys Evans
Smith 7-got forward well and linked well with the attack-started most of our attacks and was decent at the back
Vincent 7-steady improvement
Ifil 7-won loads,great goal
Williams 7-becoming the best skipper since Taylor
Shakes 8-our biggest threat
Timlin 8-works tirelessly,mops things up,great commited tackler,but should have equalised
Pook 6-better than last week but I still cant wait for Weston/Evans to come back and replace him
Zaboub 6 and a half-again touches of brilliance but little end product today-just the one superb cross
Peacock 7-held the ball up well in difficult conditions
Roberts 6-so promising at times early on but faded badly
Sturrock 6-I think he looks sound
Brown 6-decent shout for a pen from where I stood

[Simon Pieman]

Timlin is 21...22 in march.