Ratings

[adje]

Smith-10 perfect in every way,unbelievable saves
Smith-7 steady reliable
Williams-9 fucking immense
Ifil-8-love it when after a superb tackle/intervention he lumps it in the stand
Vincent-7 best I've seen from him
Shakes-7 the nutmeg on Ginger to win the corner that led to the goal was priceless,worked hard and did fair share of chasing back
Timlin 8-superb did the work of two men,superb set piece for the goal
Pook 5-sorry,lamentable-especially his two"attempts" on goal
Zaboub-7 touches of class but should have scored twice
Peacock-8 best game for weeks good hold up play and neat lay offs plus usual workrate
Roberts-6 brilliant free kick but little else

[DV]

Smith - 7 - Only a 7 from me, some good saves first half and a very important penatly save. Went to pot in the second half. About three occasions he didnt come off his line and clear it. I dont know if he decided to not come off his line incase it held up in the wind or what. The one where he didnt come, then did and him and Williams kicked each other could have proved costly

Smith - 7 - steady as usual
Williams - 8 - Immense
Ifil - 8  - The beast at his best, like McLeod is worth 1m+  
Vincent - 7 - solid

Shakes - 7 - very hard working, very decent game
Pook - 5 - might as well have not been there
Timlin - 7 - good performance, had to do the job of two men
Zaaboub - 8 - Ace, sign him up now. Pure quality should have scored one or even two

Roberts - 6 - Lazy and had the first touch of a ricky shakes! usless
Peacock - 8 - Quality, well taken scrambled goal. Good flick ons and some top defensive work in the last 10

[Chubbs]

Smith- 9  Great performance, Fantastic in every way, would be a 10 if he saved 2 like brez.
Smith- 7 Reasonable game, did the job.
Williams- 8 Great game, really holds the back 4 in position
Ifil- 8 Solid defending, don't take any shit
Vincent- 6 Didn't realy pay much attention to him
Shakes- 8 Well impresed with him, skimmin player and even put a few good crosses in and a few shots
Timlin-7 1/2 Not as good as he's been recently, a few poor passes but yet still solid and did well
Pook- Not even gonna give him a rating, he was utter shite today
Zaboob- 8 1/2 I hope we keep him and he wants to stay, he's got fantastic feet and when he took on 3 defenders was just great, right at the end.
Peacock- 7 Still needs to make an effort on high balls, atleast make it look as if he's trying, but still played well when he had the ball
Roberts- 7 Didint really do too much, but had a few good spells, still i find when a deep ball is comming in he automaticaly spins the defender thinking the defender is going to fumble and the ball will come to him, theres no need, challenge for it in the air.

[Bartek]

Shakes- 8 Well impresed with him, skimmin player and even put a few good crosses in and a few shots

The dance lessons give some efects  

[DV]

Smith- 9  Great performance, Fantastic in every way, would be a 10 if he saved 2 like brez.
Smith- 7 Reasonable game, did the job.
Williams- 8 Great game, really holds the back 4 in position
Ifil- 8 Solid defending, don't take any shit
Vincent- 6 Didn't realy pay much attention to him
Shakes- 8 Well impresed with him, skimmin player and even put a few good crosses in and a few shots
Timlin-7 1/2 Not as good as he's been recently, a few poor passes but yet still solid and did well
Pook- Not even gonna give him a rating, he was utter shite today
Zaboob- 8 1/2 I hope we keep him and he wants to stay, he's got fantastic feet and when he took on 3 defenders was just great, right at the end.
Peacock- 7 Still needs to make an effort on high balls, atleast make it look as if he's trying, but still played well when he had the ball
Roberts- 7 Didint really do too much, but had a few good spells, still i find when a deep ball is comming in he automaticaly spins the defender thinking the defender is going to fumble and the ball will come to him, theres no need, challenge for it in the air.

no way to roberts and peacock deserve the same rating...

[Chubbs]

maybe not, what u gonna do? :twak:

[sonic youth]

P Smith Couple of excellent saves but looked a little panicky at times, not quite as commanding as usual. 7
J Smith Given some cover ahead of him had a much more solid game. 7
Ifil A few rushes of blood to the head leading to some rash challenges and being found out of position but otherwise solid. Dealt with McLeod's pace well. 7
Williams Steadily and unspectacularly solid. 7
Shakes Best I've seen him play for awhile - perhaps being dropped has made him hungrier? Got forward to good effect and had a couple of good chances saved. 8
Pook No comment needed. 4
Timlin So painfully one-footed but as DV said he had to do the job of two men today. 8
Zaaboub He can dribble, he can cross, he can beat a man, he's superb. Sign him up. I wish his late chance had gone in that would have been the greatest goal of the season without doubt. 8
Roberts Ineffective for the most part, ironic given he's been better out wide. 6
Peacock Threatened on a few occasions but was fortunate with his goal. 7

Strangely I thought the midfield was good today given the fact Pook was anonymous and MK were very physical...

[deltaincline]

Smith-10
Smith-7
Williams-9
Ifil-8
Vincent-7
Shakes-7
Timlin 8
Pook 5-sorry,lamentable-especially his two"attempts" on goal
Zaboub-7
Peacock-8
Roberts-6

Agree with the above sentiments. Pook was awful today. I honestly thought he was no better than sunday league standard under Kinky and Iffy. Wise got him playing well though and he deserved his place on merit at the start of the season. Under Sturrock he has gone backwards and is playing worse than he was pre-wise. Not blaming Sturrock, just a sad observation of someone who can play much better football but isn't doing so for whatever reason.

[Chubbs]

sonic, i know vincent wasnt the gratest player on the pitch but he deserves a rating, (unlike pook)

[sonic youth]

i always forget vincent. i think it's a sign.

[Arriba]

was pook really that bad?
cannot comment as i wasn't there

[Chubbs]

he was worse than bad, i'd swear is was 12 v 10 coz every pass he made went to them.

[Arriba]

you all seem agreed he was poor so i'll take your word for it!

[justboiledover]

wasn't there today, but a comment on vincent. i never notice him when he's playing which means i've never noticed an opponents right winger geting the better of him! i quite like him, steady if not too great going forwards but you don't get too many paul bodins at this level.

[Spud]

Nice to hear that Williams had another good game, yet you still get some idiots saying he's past it.  :nuts: