Is it out? Beefy decides

[larwood]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/cricket/4975832.stm

Of course it won't be up to Beefy,be good if it was though
Personally i'm not sure about this,will LBW's be questioned?Catches will be i'm sure,but that was a problem before,sometimes because T.V is a two dimension thing you aren't able to tell if the ball has been caught clearly or not.And what about the Umpires?I think on the whole they do a great job,they make some mistakes but they get it right mostly.I think the ICC are fucking around with our wonderful game again,a la the subs rule :roll:

[DMR]

" Umpires at international level already get between 94% and 96% of decisions correct " - ICC general manager Dave Richardson

hahaha that's utter rubbish

[Spud]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/cricket/4975832.stm

Of course it won't be up to Beefy,be good if it was though
Personally i'm not sure about this,will LBW's be questioned?Catches will be i'm sure,but that was a problem before,sometimes because T.V is a two dimension thing you aren't able to tell if the ball has been caught clearly or not.And what about the Umpires?I think on the whole they do a great job,they make some mistakes but they get it right mostly.I think the ICC are fucking around with our wonderful game again,a la the subs rule :roll:

Spot on, it's a stupid idea, just as it would be stupid to start bringing in video replays in Football.

Leave the fucking Sports alone.

[Spencer_White]

The standard of umpiring has got much better in recent years in my opinion.

Far too much meddling in all forms and levels of the game now.

[larwood]

" Umpires at international level already get between 94% and 96% of decisions correct " - ICC general manager Dave Richardson

Also if its true,why the fuck are they on about doing this?Video replays will just undermine the umpires,there really don't do a bad job,and to my mind bad decisions even themselves out over the course of a series anyway.
Its a waste of time :-))(

[Boeta]

The standard of umpiring has got much better in recent years in my opinion.

didnt watch the sa v aus series then? that was a series of muggings