He was crap from day 1 bamboo. And depressingly consistent too.
I thought he was showing signs of improvement toward the end of his time with us. It was too late by then, the damage had been on both sides, in terms of the defence's confidence in him and his confidence being shot to shit. Which by the sounds of it has continued into his first game back with United. I'm with bamboo, it was just completely the wrong move for him, he was left way too exposed.