ratings v scunthopre

[Spencer_White]

Nicholas' first touch was a disgrace. But he was at least in some way effective.

Id give Gurney a 4, max. I didnt think he worked hard at all.

In regards to McDermot, really regret giving away Steve Robinson now. Old head, knew the club, had seen things turned around before.

[DV]

Heaton - Some good saves - 7

Jenkins - People keep saying unfit, be fair Peter Beagrie is still a good player, anyone at right back would have had been given the run around and he was never going to get cover from Roberts - 5

O'Hanlon - Thought he was rather solid, wasted possesion - 6

Gurney - Mixed bag again, some good passes some crap ones. Still hitting the wall with EVERY free kick he has taken - 6

Nicholas - Very poor first touch, other than that he did ok - 5

Roberts - Typical Christian Roberts, one minuted he looked like a fat lazy sack of shit, the next minute he was skinning 3 players at once. Needs to be less greedy. Glad he stuck the penalty away though - 6

McDermott - why, just why?

Whalley - Still doesnt look fit enough - 5

Pook - Looked a yard off the pace, maybe he needs a rest - 5

Bouazza - Awesome, got the ball at his feet and wasnt scared to run at players. Work very hard, did everything Christian Roberts should be doing. When does he go back - 8

Fallon - Was a complete twat today, not the first time he's done it either. Rubbish & Dustbins away on Boxing day anyway. Iffy was going to bring on Thorpe after Rory got his talking to, just didnt do it quick enough. First time this season he has let us down - 2

-----

Charlie Coymn-Platt - Looked very solid I though, much perfer to Paddy Collins and he offers something different to Ifil. Wasnt afraid to get stuck in and distribution wasnt too shoddy - 7

[santini]

Phil King said he was probably our best player first half?

Probably more interested in his impact on the game than on his 'poor first touch'.

[santini]

Most of the listeners on here had to listen to the Scunthorpe Commentary as STFC World couldn't get Swindon Commentary!

They definately didn't rate him at all.

They had him down as a centre back and couldn't understand why he was on the left. That really confused them. They were so petulant and biased - it was like listening to a bunch of schoolkids having a go at anyone in our side who did anything against their 'brilliant' team.

[le god cuervo]

comyn-platt was ace when he come on. seemed to be in the right position all the time & made some good clearances. i hope he stays in the team over ifil. he definatly looks less likely to make stupid mistakes.

shame about rory's sending off, it was a blatent elbow & probably wouldv'e been a straight red anyway. shouldn't have been booked for the dive, that should've been a pen.

i thought whalley was playing ok until he went off, seems to be getting more involved now & making more tackles. he's improved since the start of the season IMO.

i thought ricky shakes played well too when he came on. didnt expect him to be any good in the centre but he put himself about a bit. hope he starts in place of fallon at huddersfield.

[walrus]

Gurney 10 - Zidanesque passes, genius wind-up tactics, commited, ran like a fucking dog and was geniunely amazing.  I was very impressed, though did get caught of position sometimes.  Sign him up!  

[Compo]

Gurney rocks...................

Has allways done........................................soapy tit wank