Thetownend.com

25% => The Reg Smeeton Match Day Action/Reaction Forum => Topic started by: Piemonte on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 12:51:31



Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: Piemonte on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 12:51:31
bit of an essay, but I'm bored.

Evans - 7 - other than get booked for (rightfully) confronting Byfiled after his slightly bizzare and unneccessary chalenge he didnt really have anything to do did he?

J Smith - 8 - Defended well, some decent balls going forward

Nicholas - 8 - Same as smith really, just seemed to get up and down a little more. Excellent comedy effort of standing on the ball late on in  the TE / NW corner :D

O'Hanlon - 8 Solid, reilable

Ifill - 8 - same as sean'o. In gerneral the defence is looking solid.

P Smith - 7 - was doing well before getting injured.

Gurney -4-  Worst player on the pitch for me. positionally poor, shit distribution. no matter what the circmustances seemed to make the wrong decision.

Shakes - 7 - Not as good as the last 2 home games but still effective.

Brown - 7- a decent hardworking performance I thought. unremarkable.

Cureton -7- played well, another great finish. gets marked down for being a greedy cunt in the 2nd half. has a tendancy to take too many touches

The Cock -8- As Iffy said, great work rate. Offers a good physical presence up front. Ref didnt seem to like him much, got a load of free kick awarded against him. I have faith that the goals will come.

SUBS:
 Migs - 6- did alright i thought.

Roberts -5- dont want to be harsh as it was good to see him back, but he wasnt very good was he? I'm sure he'll get better though

IFFY - 8- got the team selection right (to be fair it did pretty much pick itself though. Personally I'd have given uncle Albert a go down the left with 15 mins left, but there you go.

Needs to stop the defence dropping so fucking deep late on, although that is something that has been a problem for years now.


Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: Johno on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 13:02:37
i agree with pie...espically on nicho, what an effort.  :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick:


Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: Tails on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 13:04:58
Agree with all of it. Rhys likes the odd confrontation doesn't he.

We need to learn how to kill teams off.


Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: janaage on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 13:16:44
Killing teams off is boring, I love these nervous endings to our matches at the moment, real adrenaline rush at the final whistle.

Although I wouldn't mind if we managed a couple of 4 or 5 nils.


Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: reeves4england on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 13:35:22
Last night it was a stroll for the players, which makes it hard to give them high ratings

Evans 6 - Did almost nothing but make easy saves. Came off his line well

Shakes 6 - Pace is great but im not joking when I say I could have scored that chance

Gurns 4 - He was playing?!

Ifil 7 - Made some great tackles and is in good form

Curo 7 - Ran around a lot all game and stretched the defence. Should have scored atleast one more

Roberts 5 - only had a few touches and did nothing wrong


Title: Ratings v Gills
Post by: DV on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 14:28:18
Would give Gurney a higher rating, not much higher but he was better than a 4.....again did the ugly work no one notices....


Title: Re: Ratings v Gills
Post by: STFC Village on Wednesday, February 15, 2006, 15:36:27
Quote from: "Piemonte"
Nicholas -Excellent comedy effort of standing on the ball late on in  the TE / NW corner :D
I thought that was Shakes? Oh, no, it was both of them :D