Thetownend.com

25% => The Reg Smeeton Match Day Action/Reaction Forum => Topic started by: Arriba on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 22:51:15



Title: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Arriba on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 22:51:15
plenty of stuff about pubs,trains,yobs,tickets,etc but we aint got into the game itself really.

i've thought quite alot about how we should go about trying to win on sat, and i cant decide if we line up and play as we have pretty much all season,or change our game a bit.
millwall are bang up for this game,and having lost last year we can guarantee they will take some beating.i think we can do it,but i'm not sure our current formation will be the way to go.

i've wondered if maybe playing ward in the hole behind the front 2 might be worth a go.i've wondered if we just go 4,4,2 and hope that's good enough to see us through.
millwall will have done their homework on us,and maybe playing a ward in the hole would cause them problems?they wouldn't have prepared for it,and will have to change things to counter it.

i still dont know what i think is the right way to go really.i just hope we are better than them and win.i'm sure danny will have them well prepared.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 22:56:32
I'm hoping that Millwall being favourites and them losing last year will heap a lot more unwanted pressure on them, We are the underdogs so maybe it will work in our favour like it did with Blackpool yesterday?


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 22:57:18
If we play to our best I think we'll win. Personally I don't see what all the fuss about Millwall is. They were pretty average in both games against us and pretty poor in both legs of their semi. They're nothing special. Just a well organised team that are hard to break down. They do it the unfashionable way but it works for them. Now i'm far from saying they are not a threat. As Arriba says they will be well up for it. We need to be good in the centre of the park and in the final third. I think them being away from The Den will help us as well.

We should just go 4-4-2. Forget what has happened in the past games etc this is a one off. It's a 50/50 toss up between 2 teams and the one that handles the pressure and turns up on the day will win. I would personally start with Manks at RB over Darby. Other than that it's as you were with LJF at CB and Sheehan at LB. The team pretty much takes care of itself for me.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: wiggy on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 22:58:57
I think pace will be our best option against the Wall. Maybe start with the line up that started against Charlton at home in the first leg - keep Billy on the bench until their centre backs are knackered.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:00:52
I would like to see Amankwaah start but got a feeling this will be the team:

Lucas, Darby, Sheehan, Cuthbert, Lescinel, McGovern, Ferry, Douglas (Capt), Ward, Austin Paynter, SUBS: Smith, Morrison, Easton, Timlin, Nouble, Pericard, Amankwaah.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Talk Talk on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:02:12
After watching the semis against Hudders I don't think we have anything to worry about. They are really really shit hoofball merchants too.

Just keep it on the deck and pass it around - there is loads of room at Wembley.

Play our passing game and we will shit in their mouths.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Tails on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:02:31
To be completely honest I don't think we'll win. I think we'll give a good account of ourselves but we'll fall short IMO, Millwall are a very good side and unfortunately for us are due a win at Wembley in the playoffs.

Play how we've played all season, stick with the same formation and just give it a go - that's all we can ask for.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:03:54
After watching the semis against Hudders I don't think we have anything to worry about. They are really really shit hoofball merchants too.

Just keep it on the deck and pass it around - there is loads of room at Wembley.

Play our passing game and we will shit in their mouths.

This but only if we play it well. Slack defending will cost us dear. Must be on our game in all departments really.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:04:04
To be completely honest I don't think we'll win. I think we'll give a good account of ourselves but we'll fall short IMO, Millwall are a very good side and unfortunately for us are due a win at Wembley in the playoffs.

Play how we've played all season, stick with the same formation and just give it a go - that's all we can ask for.

That's how i have been thinking  :( :( They are definitely due a win and will be very fired up, They are very good defensively and hard to break down, We could win it though, We have a chance so i'm not going to be too negative.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: joteddyred on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:04:44

We should just go 4-4-2. Forget what has happened in the past games etc this is a one off. It's a 50/50 toss up between 2 teams and the one that handles the pressure and turns up on the day will win. I would personally start with Manks at RB over Darby. Other than that it's as you were with LJF at CB and Sheehan at LB. The team pretty much takes care of itself for me.

Agree with this completely.  Hopefully having played Millwall only a couple of weeks ago will be a benefit, as we will know the players they utilise the most.  They are a difficult team to break down, but we were far from our best that day and we still got 2 past them.  Do we know whether Sheehan is fit again?


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:05:37
First of all, the absolute worst thing we can do is change our style from what we've been doing all season.

The team largely picks itself. Assuming the players who have had injuries (Lucas, Sheehan) are fit, the only decision is whether to play Darby or Amankwaah at right back. Even that to me, is not a decision. It has to be Manks..far more positive and that's what you need. We have to take the game to them.

Millwall obviously have an excellent home record where they have come to use the hostile home crowd to their advantage but that will be taken away from them next Saturday...yes they will have 30,000 plus fans behind them but that will be cancelled out by 30,000 plus Town fans...get them out on the wide open spaces of Wembley and I think we will prove that we have the better players.

It will be as hard as fuck but I believe that we can and will beat them.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Talk Talk on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:06:10
Do we know whether Sheehan is fit again?

A very good point.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Batch on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:06:24
I think pace will be our best option against the Wall. Maybe start with the line up that started against Charlton at home in the first leg - keep Billy on the bench until their centre backs are knackered.

With Billy being injured we certainly found a different, more pacey,  way of attacking

But its the other way round for me, start with the 'normal' starting 11 and we have manks and O'Brien to come on and make the switch of Ward up front.

Its a tough call.

Can we beat Millwall. Yes.
Can Millwall beat us. Yes.
Who knows what will happen on the day, I reckon it'll come down to a bit of luck here or a bad decision there.

Not having Greer is a big loss, but if Lecs is on his game he'll be OK. Just hope Paynter, Sheehan and Lucas are fit, though Smith is no bad cover for Lucas.



Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:08:35
and unfortunately for us are due a win at Wembley in the playoffs.


That is bollocks man! No one is a due a win! That is supersticious bollocks ::)

Oh well, they're due a win. Let's not bother turning up!


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Barry Scott on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:08:48
What's the news on Sheehan? I've heard nothing about how bad his injury is/was (apart from a few lines about a hip injury) and have no idea when he's back. Will he play?

Millwall are an organised side and are tough to break down. We can absolutely out-football them and, state of the pitch excused, we should be more than capable of doing that regardless of the starting line-up.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:10:09
What's the news on Sheehan? I've heard nothing about how bad his injury is/was (apart from a few lines about a hip injury) and have no idea when he's back. Will he play?

Millwall are an organised side and are tough to break down. We can absolutely out-football them and, state of the pitch excused, we should be more than capable of doing that regardless of the starting line-up.

He said on the radio on Monday that he would be out for 10 days so it's pushing it, He may not be fully fit.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Batch on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:10:10
Oh yeah, plus we have had a days extra rest :)


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: STFC Bart on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:11:07
To be honest it is anyones game.

Do not see how everyone raves about Millwall- away from the den their away record is not great- won 7, drawn 8, lost 8- our away record by contrast is better.

Them being away from the den and the wembley pitch i think will be a good leveller. Also think we have the better players overall.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Batch on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:11:27
He said on the radio on Monday that he would be out for 10 days so it's pushing it, He may not be fully fit.

Arse, if this is fact then it could be the difference. Though we could start Derby and Manks which isn't a disaster, no Greer too is stretching it.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:12:29

Them being away from the den and the wembley pitch i think will be a good leveller. Also think we have the better players overall.

Yep. Agree with that Bartholomew 8)


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:13:28
Though we could start Derby and Manks which isn't a disaster

That would actually be OK.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Bert1981 on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:14:54
I would like to see us go with Austin & Ward upfront. Look at the semi-finals, we caused Charlton loads of problems with them 2 up top but were completely ineffective with Paynter on the pitch. Ok I know he wasn't fully fit, but the same was true at Millwall on the last day, their centre backs had Austin & Paynter in their pockets from what I understand.

Ward would give them something completely different to think about. If we use Paynter as a target man we will play into their hands completely. The way to beat them is to get the ball on the floor and move it quickly.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Batch on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:16:03
But you don't think Wilson will drop our top scorer do you (if fit)?

Nor should he IMHO.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Doore on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:16:17
Alternatively, perhaps we should start with our top scorer who is close to 30 goals for the season.  I'm radical, me.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:16:39
I would like to see us go with Austin & Ward upfront. Look at the semi-finals, we caused Charlton loads of problems with them 2 up top but were completely ineffective with Paynter on the pitch. Ok I know he wasn't fully fit, but the same was true at Millwall on the last day, their centre backs had Austin & Paynter in their pockets from what I understand.

Ward would give them something completely different to think about. If we use Paynter as a target man we will play into their hands completely. The way to beat them is to get the ball on the floor and move it quickly.

Can see your point but i thought O'Brien was awful at Charlton and every final ball of his was terrible and ended up going to their players or going out of play.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:17:06
But you don't think Wilson will drop our top scorer do you (if fit)?

Nor should he IMHO.

If you believe City fans then yes. They're still moaning about how he left Leroy Lita out of their squad in the 2004 final.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:19:35
It seemed to me that prior to the first leg, Charlton's defenders had been preparing to play Billy and when it was announced just before kick off that he wasn't playing they were like, "Oh fuck, what do we do now" and Charlie and Danny caused them all sorts of problems.

For the second leg of course, Billy came back in and their defenders were saying, "thank fuck, now we know what to do"...so maybe Danny will spring a surprise.

Billy on the bench?

It's a funny, fickle old game ::)


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Bert1981 on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:22:29
It seemed to me that prior to the first leg, Charlton's defenders had been preparing to play Billy and when it was announced just before kick off that he wasn't playing they were like, "Oh fuck, what do we do now" and Charlie and Danny caused them all sorts of problems.

For the second leg of course, Billy came back in and their defenders were saying, "thank fuck, now we know what to do"...so maybe Danny will spring a surprise.

Billy on the bench?

It's a funny, fickle old game ::)

I think that's what I was trying to get at! Maybe leaving Paynter out is a bit radical, but I do think we should play Ward in a more advanced central role, so arriba's suggestion of putting him behind the front 2 would be a good compromise!


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Barry Scott on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:23:47
It seemed to me that prior to the first leg, Charlton's defenders had been preparing to play Billy and when it was announced just before kick off that he wasn't playing they were like, "Oh fuck, what do we do now" and Charlie and Danny caused them all sorts of problems.

Danny eluded to this in his post-match comments. He said that he'd known Billy was injured for a long before the game, but the whole squad were sworn to secrecy as he wanted that element of surprise. I wouldn't be surprised at all. Perhaps even the unthinkable might happen: Charlie on the bench...


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:31:09
Paynter looked unfit at Charlton but that would be understandable, Hopefully he will be fully fit for the Final.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Doore on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:33:12
Danny eluded to this in his post-match comments. He said that he'd known Billy was injured for a long before the game, but the whole squad were sworn to secrecy as he wanted that element of surprise. I wouldn't be surprised at all. Perhaps even the unthinkable might happen: Charlie on the bench...

Lets really surprise them and drop Cuthbert, Douglas, Ward, McGovern, Austin and Paynter.  They'd never expect that, so we'd be bound to win.


My point being - in the big games, play your best players in their best positions, and let them do their jobs.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Rustle on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:33:26
I agree they done their homework on us when we visited the den,but we had to win that game and although we have to win this one aswell we dont have to go like a bull at gate.I think wembley will suit our style if we can get the ball down and spread it about and get the ball out to the wide men,what we dont need is for them to stop us from doing that and then for us to start hoofing it up to the front pair,that would be playing into millwalls hands.

We can outplay them as we have the players to do that but they are a lot more physical which does worry me especially if the ref is lenient.

I wasn't impressed by them against huddersfield but saying that all they had to do was turn up.

Just one more leeds type of performance and we'll be in the championship next season.



Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: joteddyred on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:34:11
Danny eluded to this in his post-match comments. He said that he'd known Billy was injured for a long before the game, but the whole squad were sworn to secrecy as he wanted that element of surprise. I wouldn't be surprised at all. Perhaps even the unthinkable might happen: Charlie on the bench...

It might not be completely unthinkable.  A couple of my mates saw young Mr Austin out and about in town last night and reckon he was limping slightly.  Of course, he may have just had one to many, but knowing our luck?  


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: STFC Bart on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:34:59
And like i said earlier- away from the den they aint all  that


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pride_of_wilts on Sunday, May 23, 2010, 23:41:11
Like others have said we need to stick to our game plan and pass the ball around and try and get a hold of the game, Start hoofing the ball to Austin & Paynter and their defence which is fairly solid anyway will have a field day and we won't get anywhere.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Nijholts Nuts on Monday, May 24, 2010, 00:42:12
Play our passing game and we will shit in their mouths.

 :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick:


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: DV on Monday, May 24, 2010, 10:40:37
The 4-4-2 formation with Austin and Paynter up top has done us well this season, so we should stick with it.

I expect if Millwall have done their homework they have probably prepared for both Paynter & Austin and Ward & Austin. For Charlton it was a pretty new scenario, Ward upfront but after the two play off games and Ward scoring in both, and getting man of the match - Millwall are going to be well aware of the fact we might start him upfront so will be sorted for that to.

If everyone is fit.

Lucas

Amankwaah
Cuthbert
LJF
Sheehan

JPM
Douglas
Ferry
Ward

Austin
Paynter

practically picks itself.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: magicroundabout on Monday, May 24, 2010, 10:45:36

If everyone is fit.

Lucas

Amankwaah
Cuthbert
LJF
Sheehan

JPM
Douglas
Ferry
Ward

Austin
Paynter

practically picks itself.

i definitely think Mancs should play over Darby. not taking anything away from the lad but feel Mancs offers us more of a presence and a decent attacking option.

I would say the weakest part of that team is JFL at CB but after his performance at Charlton i'd be happy for him to start


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Gnasher on Monday, May 24, 2010, 10:57:09
Where's Morrison these days? Would be a massive gamble but so is JFL!


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pauld on Monday, May 24, 2010, 10:59:21
Where's Morrison these days? Would be a massive gamble but so is JFL!
Not at centre-half he's not. Oh, and according to this morning's Adver, sounds like both Billy and Sheehan are "maybes" but Wilson won't play anyone who isn't 100% fit, he'll see how they go in training this week. I know, astonishing isn't it?


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: magicroundabout on Monday, May 24, 2010, 11:08:00
i believe they will all start. 10 days to rest a tight hamstring and groin are long enough i'd say. Lucas is the only one pushing to get fully fit. he looked in a lot of pain at charlton.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Gnasher on Monday, May 24, 2010, 11:10:48
Not at centre-half he's not. Oh, and according to this morning's Adver, sounds like both Billy and Sheehan are "maybes" but Wilson won't play anyone who isn't 100% fit, he'll see how they go in training this week. I know, astonishing isn't it?

He's either the best player on the pitch or a liability, this makes him a gamble. Hopefully he'll have the game of his life at Wembley.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Ardiles on Monday, May 24, 2010, 11:16:49
Not at centre-half he's not. Oh, and according to this morning's Adver, sounds like both Billy and Sheehan are "maybes" but Wilson won't play anyone who isn't 100% fit, he'll see how they go in training this week. I know, astonishing isn't it?

Billy was a long way from 100% fit at Charlton!  I hope DW sticks to this.  If Billy's not back to full fitness in time for Saturday, he shouldn't start.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: DV on Monday, May 24, 2010, 11:19:55
He's either the best player on the pitch or a liability, this makes him a gamble. Hopefully he'll have the game of his life at Wembley.

Morrison didnt exactly cover himself in glory the last time he played for us, away at MK.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: pauld on Monday, May 24, 2010, 11:30:32
Billy was a long way from 100% fit at Charlton!  I hope DW sticks to this.  If Billy's not back to full fitness in time for Saturday, he shouldn't start.
Sorry, I should have clarified - that was what it said in the Adver in ref to Wembley game rather than me making wild statements about DW's overall philosophy :)


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Arriba on Monday, May 24, 2010, 12:32:53
i have no worries at all about ljf playing centre back.he's bloody good there.
i'm more concerned about who is gonna be left back, and how we take the game to millwall.


Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: jonny72 on Monday, May 24, 2010, 12:45:23
I'd like to have seen Ward given a few games playing just behind the front two as when he played in that position against Norwich he had one of his best games of the season. But the playoff final isn't the time to start experimenting.

The team will pretty much pick itself dependent on injuries, the only questions being who plays at right back if Sheehan is fit (if he isn't it will be Darby on the left and Manks on the right) and who plays left midfield if Paynter isn't fit. I'd go with Darby and Marshall as O'Brien just hasn't been with it in the last couple of games, still can't figure out why Marshall is suddenly out of favour after the good performances he put in on the left.



Title: Re: a thread about the the match itself
Post by: Arriba on Monday, May 24, 2010, 12:49:16
by playing ward in the hole with a 3 man midfield,would cause millwall all kinds of problems.it is a nightmare to defend against.the more i think about it, the more i like it.if it doesn't work he can always shift back to the left and go 4,4,2 again.i like mcgovern tucking in(superb at charlton doing that)so changing things aint too much of a gamble.
as long as the right and left backs bomb on, then i think it could work