Thetownend.com

25% => Players => Topic started by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:32:14



Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:32:14
up front next saturday please

If Roberts cant be arsed to run, put effort it or even challenge for the ball then he should be dropped

I was amazed and pretty pissed off that lazy Roberts came out for the 2nd half and Caton went off (unless he was injured, havnt heard after match interviews)

Caton was running at players, taking them on....look lively full of energy and was challenging for and winning headers.

About time he was given a proper chance up top


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Samdy Gray on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:32:43
Seconded


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: mr ian on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:35:04
thirdededed


Title: Re: Andy Caton...
Post by: SwindonTownFC on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:36:50
Quote from: "DV85"
up front next saturday please

If Roberts cant be arsed to run, put effort it or even challenge for the ball then he should be dropped

I was amazed and pretty pissed off that lazy Roberts came out for the 2nd half and Caton went off (unless he was injured, havnt heard after match interviews)

Caton was running at players, taking them on....look lively full of energy and was challenging for and winning headers.

About time he was given a proper chance up top


u having a laugh?? Caton was fucking shit 2day, he didnt look bothered he didnt do fuck all, just went thru the motions, poorly!!


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Johno on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:37:50
I missed today so can't judge but every game roberts has tried his all...so 1 performance would be harsh to drop him, unless he really was THAT bad.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: mr ian on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:37:58
i think he deserves a chance up front


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 18:39:33
you're clearly confusing Caton with Roberts...the only time Roberts challenged was when he ran back to stupidly give a free kick in our own half a minute before half time.....which led to their goal.

Oh and he got given a golden chance in the 2nd half and hit the post, other than that he did nothing.

At least Caton was challenging....how many times did Roberts just let the peterbrough defender win the ball in the air without so much of a challenge


Title: Re: Andy Caton...
Post by: Dr Pierre Chang on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:03:35
Quote from: "SwindonTownFC"
Quote from: "DV85"
up front next saturday please

If Roberts cant be arsed to run, put effort it or even challenge for the ball then he should be dropped

I was amazed and pretty pissed off that lazy Roberts came out for the 2nd half and Caton went off (unless he was injured, havnt heard after match interviews)

Caton was running at players, taking them on....look lively full of energy and was challenging for and winning headers.

About time he was given a proper chance up top


u having a laugh?? Caton was fucking shit 2day, he didnt look bothered he didnt do fuck all, just went thru the motions, poorly!!

100% agree

Brown is much better.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:05:23
...yes that cross that went into the town end was mighty impressive....


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:24:21
id like to see Lucas up front. it's all good and well playing the "big two" but they have been shite so far (hard work or not)


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: ty on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:52:06
caton poor today, but he was not the only one, we do need a new striker he aint the answer.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: PHIL!!!! on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:55:54
It was just the other day when everyone was praising Caton!?

I think he's a great player and surely everyone is aloud an off day sometime!?

I agree that Lukas should definetly be in the frame for a starting slot.
Personally, i wouldnt mind seeing us play with an attacking midfielder...Possibly Brownlie playing behind Peacock and Roberts? Or even Roberts playing in that role with Onibuje upfront with Peacock?


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 19:57:26
i wish we signed Lambert now i really do


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Bogus Dave on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 20:04:52
fuck sake. lets just get some fucking perspective here. So far this season, roberts has been a completely new player, and people having been ssaying how great he is. He even won player of the month ffs. But he has one crap match, and now everyone wants him dropped. I know he played cack today, perhaps it was that time of the month. But you dont drop him after just one game.

If he continues in the same vain against notts county, then we can question his position. However, i dont think wise will allow that, and i can see roberts coming back with a bang in the next game.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: PHIL!!!! on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 20:10:16
Quote from: "swindon town dave"
fuck sake. lets just get some fucking perspective here. So far this season, roberts has been a completely new player, and people having been ssaying how great he is. He even won player of the month ffs. But he has one crap match, and now everyone wants him dropped. I know he played cack today, perhaps it was that time of the month. But you dont drop him after just one game.

If he continues in the same vain against notts county, then we can question his position. However, i dont think wise will allow that, and i can see roberts coming back with a bang in the next game.


Agree 100% - Good post


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: McLovin on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 20:20:33
He had a slightly off day today, but i reckon he could be a good player for us.

Agree about Roberts. He reminded me of his alcoholic workshy shite days...


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:04:48
There is a big difference between playing 'cack' as you call it and putting in no effort...

I can tolerate playing cack, not having a good game....etc....but what I cant stand is no effort.....


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:05:42
There is a big difference between playing 'cack' as you call it and putting in no effort...

I can tolerate playing cack, not having a good game....etc....but what I cant stand is no effort.....


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Bogus Dave on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:08:16
well by the term cack, i meant everything about him was awful today. However, like i said, its one game. Im sure wise will of noted his lack of effort, and will take steps to change it.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: sonic youth on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:23:46
why put caton up front? the kid prefers playing out wide by his own admission, let him focus on making that left-wing position his own and bring lukas in, who seems to have become the forgotten man of late.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:31:01
when did Caton say he perfered playing outwide. I must have missed that.

I was under the impression he was a striker?


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: sonic youth on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:33:10
it's been in the adver a few times this week, saying that he was asked to play out wide in a youth/reserve game by ian woan as he thought caton had potential there. he's been playing there ever since.

in his own words, he likes running at people and taking them on, so it suits him.

i'd find the link but i cannot be fucking bothered.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 21:34:39
still reckon he'd make a good striker though....


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Simon Pieman on Saturday, September 16, 2006, 23:36:23
The problem I saw today was that Caton drifted inside too much and Roberts went too wide.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: SwindonTownFC on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 11:05:14
Quote from: "DV85"
still reckon he'd make a good striker though....


to lightweight at the moment, the centre backs in this league wud fucking murder him he is better as a left winger, DV how can u sum up browns performance by 1 cross?? u referred to it about 3 times, u say u cant judge Caton on 1 game yet your judging Browns performance yesterday on 1 cross


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Bennett on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 11:50:00
i think you can judge someone performance by how much effort they put in. just like the majority of the team there was little to no effort. where as caton ran like he wanted the ball, unlike brown who ran. then stopped and had a nap


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: reeves4england on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 12:06:47
I think considering that's only ou first home defeat of the season, we need to put it into perspective. Roberts has played well this year and although I didn't see him yesterday, he must have been pretty aweful to cancel out all the good work he's done so far and deserve to be dropped

Give Wisey the next game to sort things out before you start slagging off his team selection - maybe he will just give them a kick up the arse and they will get back to winning ways?!


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 16:35:25
Quote from: "SwindonTownFC"
Quote from: "DV85"
still reckon he'd make a good striker though....


to lightweight at the moment, the centre backs in this league wud fucking murder him he is better as a left winger, DV how can u sum up browns performance by 1 cross?? u referred to it about 3 times, u say u cant judge Caton on 1 game yet your judging Browns performance yesterday on 1 cross


Doesnt matter how you're built if you've got the ability to run through people like Caton does...the pace and close control that Caton was would scare most league 2 centre backs.

I havent judged Brown at all....infact I think he should play on the left, I think he is our best option....however yesterday, like everyone else he was usless...and his final ball was truely fucking awful (not that he was only in that)


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: SwindonTownFC on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 16:44:50
Quote from: "DV85"
Quote from: "SwindonTownFC"
Quote from: "DV85"
still reckon he'd make a good striker though....


to lightweight at the moment, the centre backs in this league wud fucking murder him he is better as a left winger, DV how can u sum up browns performance by 1 cross?? u referred to it about 3 times, u say u cant judge Caton on 1 game yet your judging Browns performance yesterday on 1 cross


Doesnt matter how you're built if you've got the ability to run through people like Caton does...the pace and close control that Caton was would scare most league 2 centre backs.

I havent judged Brown at all....infact I think he should play on the left, I think he is our best option....however yesterday, like everyone else he was usless...and his final ball was truely fucking awful (not that he was only in that)


i was saying the way we played yesterday with the long ball would be no good for Caton, thats why Roberts was so shit


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: DV on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 16:48:09
suppose...but at least Caton was challenging and trying to win the ball....Roberts just stood there....I think Caton would have put in more effort to try and get the ball


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: SwindonTownFC on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 16:51:44
am i the only 1 who thought Caton didnt look interested at all? he tracked players back but never tried to win the ball, like Duke used to, just run alongside the player. Don't get me wrong i like Caton think in the future will be a big player for us and although he was poor yesterday id be happy for him to start at Notts County


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Samdy Gray on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 17:09:08
I've heard that Chelsea are looking at Caton at the moment. Probably bollocks but thought I'd post it none the less.


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: SwindonTownFC on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 17:41:19
Quote from: "sam_stfc"
I've heard that Chelsea are looking at Caton at the moment. Probably bollocks but thought I'd post it none the less.


yeah to replace Robben  :roll:  :roll:


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Samdy Gray on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 17:43:20
I did say it was probably bollocks. One of their youth scouts was there on Saturday apparently. That should have put them off.  :mrgreen:


Title: Andy Caton...
Post by: Dazzza on Sunday, September 17, 2006, 17:57:25
To be fair Chelsea seem to be hoovering youth up like a Westbrook nostril on a Columbian sabbatical.

Plus our old mucker Jimmy Fraiser is now head of their youth set-up so it wouldn’t be surprising to see them sniffing about.