|
Title: ratings v col utd Post by: DMR on Monday, December 26, 2005, 20:41:51 evans- one real top drawer save and good kicking- 8
smith- thought he was pretty wasteful on the ball and poor positioning- 5 o'hanlon- struggled early on but got better against that effing donkey iwelumo- 7 ifil- ok his distribution is atrocious but he won EVERY tackle except a soft one near the end where he lay down- 8 nicholas- faded a bit after a superb first half, solid as hell and useful in attack- 8 (probably my motm) shakes- wonderful first half, worked hard too, fits and spells later on- 7.5 migs- was either very good or very bad- 6 mcdermott- a real workhorse performance, i thought he was unlucky to be subbed but to be fair we opened up alot more- 6 brown- a couple of class runs in the second half, made one for pook who should have buried it, went unnoticed but covered well when nicho got forawrd, underrated player- 7 fallon- utter rubbish to begin with, second half was better, brave goal- 6 holgate- enthusiasm, yes. ability to run straight at players, stay on his feet etc, no- 5 thought bouazza should have come on earlier, and pook did well. go on then, tear it apart. Title: ratings v col utd Post by: STFC Village on Monday, December 26, 2005, 20:45:01 I'd only disagree with Holgate's rating
Title: ratings v col utd Post by: DMR on Monday, December 26, 2005, 20:46:15 i hate holgate though.
Title: ratings v col utd Post by: DiV on Monday, December 26, 2005, 20:46:57 Miglioranzi was better than a 6
Holgate was better than a 5 Title: ratings v col utd Post by: STFC Village on Monday, December 26, 2005, 20:54:21 Quote from: "dave_m_russell" i hate holgate though. And i hate you for hating him.DMR- A total fucking cunt......-23 :wink: Title: ratings v col utd Post by: adje on Monday, December 26, 2005, 21:56:28 Quote from: "DV85" Miglioranzi was better than a 6 Holgate was better than a 5 Migz was MOM for me-involved in just about every good thing we did.To be honest the only class player we've got.Good to see him go in for some crunching tackles too.8 out of 10.Every one else gets a 7 'cept Brownie,6 and Pook 5.Only real downer today was our total inability to take ONE decent free kick and more than one decent corner. Title: ratings v col utd Post by: Danjackson10 on Monday, December 26, 2005, 23:12:34 I would have given Holgate a 7 0R 8!
Title: ratings v col utd Post by: Arriba on Monday, December 26, 2005, 23:17:59 no player deserves a higher score than 6,ordinary game which neither side deserved to win.fucking glad we did though!
Title: ratings v col utd Post by: my-velocity on Tuesday, December 27, 2005, 21:15:14 Quote from: "DV85" Miglioranzi was better than a 6 Holgate was better than a 5 Yup Title: ratings v col utd Post by: richiestfc on Tuesday, December 27, 2005, 21:25:41 i thought migz was utter shite!shakes did well down the side and i thought holgate worked hard but isnt good enough for first team yet. 8)
Title: Re: ratings v col utd Post by: Sue on Tuesday, December 27, 2005, 21:25:50 Quote from: "dave_m_russell" evans- one real top drawer save and good kicking- 8 smith- thought he was pretty wasteful on the ball and poor positioning- 5 o'hanlon- struggled early on but got better against that effing donkey iwelumo- 7 ifil- ok his distribution is atrocious but he won EVERY tackle except a soft one near the end where he lay down- 8 nicholas- faded a bit after a superb first half, solid as hell and useful in attack- 8 (probably my motm) shakes- wonderful first half, worked hard too, fits and spells later on- 7.5 migs- was either very good or very bad- 6 mcdermott- a real workhorse performance, i thought he was unlucky to be subbed but to be fair we opened up alot more- 6 brown- a couple of class runs in the second half, made one for pook who should have buried it, went unnoticed but covered well when nicho got forawrd, underrated player- 7 fallon- utter rubbish to begin with, second half was better, brave goal- 6 holgate- enthusiasm, yes. ability to run straight at players, stay on his feet etc, no- 5 thought bouazza should have come on earlier, and pook did well. go on then, tear it apart. I agree with all that DMR, well done :D |