|
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Kinky Tom on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:11:35 So after all this polling from DV we might as well put down our line up for Saturday.
Mine is: Code: Heaton Though we all know Heath will start, and King probably will not go with it, but I'd consider the best option. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: DiV on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:19:58 I totally 100% agree with KT on this one....
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Bedford Red on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:20:44 So do I. 8)
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: sonicyouth on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:23:04 ditto.
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: I 8 Razor on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:23:08 ...................heaton................
jenkins.....collins.....ifil.......smith shakes......pook.....migz...nicolau ...............roberts...fallon............ i wouldn't be toooo bothered if we persist with cureton TBH. and i think heath will be put on the left not nicolau Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: STFC Village on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:23:22 I think i've missed something here....how long is Seano out for?
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Kinky Tom on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:24:42 I'm just assuming he will be out, same as Evans - though I'd go with Heaton anyway, his distribution is much better.
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: STFC Village on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:30:12 Fair enough, i agree with Mr Angelinetta(sp?) then. Unless Seano is fit to play, then swap him in for Collins.
Title: Re: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: walrus on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:35:42 Mine is:
Code: Heaton Subs: Bulman Collins Whalley Cureton Shakes This would be my team with the assumption taken that O'Hanlon and Evans are out through injury. I'd like to see Thorpe given another chance, with Roberts playing but currently I just don't see their being room for him up front. It's a shame to drop Heath altogether but haven't been overly impressed, and I think Roberts gives us something different on the wing, whilst Nicholau's crossing is quality. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: BrightonRed on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:37:13 Code: Heaton I haven't been convinced by collins in either defensive position. Obviously if O'hanlon was fit he would start. I think Ifil would probably benefit from a bit of experience on either side, therefore the above would be my starting formation. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Whits on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:48:32 i bet we play 4-5-1 :D
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: adje on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:57:19 Still not convinced by Collins-or Gurney for that matter;therefore(with no O'Hanlon)
Heaton Jenkins C-Platt Ifil Smith Shakes Pook Miglioranzi Nicolau Fallon Cureton subs; Gurney,Heath,Roberts,Thorpe Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: walrus on Monday, September 5, 2005, 17:59:57 Quote from: "adje" Still not convinced by Collins-or Gurney for that matter;therefore(with no O'Hanlon) Heaton Jenkins C-Platt Ifil Smith Shakes Pook Miglioranzi Nicolau Fallon Cureton subs; Gurney,Heath,Roberts,Thorpe Is Bulman really that bad that you wouldn't even bother with him on the bench?! I forgot about C-Platt, I'm worried King's forgotten about him too. I'm always bemused by the tactic of playing a loan player (Collins) who is marginally better to one of our own (C-Platt). However, if the player is quality (Gurney) then superb :mrgreen: :beers: Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: adje on Monday, September 5, 2005, 18:53:04 Quote from: "Walrus" Quote from: "adje" Still not convinced by Collins-or Gurney for that matter;therefore(with no O'Hanlon) Heaton Jenkins C-Platt Ifil Smith Shakes Pook Miglioranzi Nicolau Fallon Cureton subs; Gurney,Heath,Roberts,Thorpe Is Bulman really that bad that you wouldn't even bother with him on the bench?! I forgot about C-Platt, I'm worried King's forgotten about him too. I'm always bemused by the tactic of playing a loan player (Collins) who is marginally better to one of our own (C-Platt). However, if the player is quality (Gurney) then superb :mrgreen: :beers: 'rus,Bulman was sort of a given(and I dont mean Shay!) Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: land_of_bo on Monday, September 5, 2005, 19:10:49 I always laugh when I see Shay on TV - Just the whole "GIVEN" and "1" undernaeath makes me wonder who has given him one :? Probs Shearer!
back to this thread, I agree with KT on formation and personnel. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Crozzer on Monday, September 5, 2005, 19:20:39 Quote from: "BrightonRed" Code: Heaton I haven't been convinced by collins in either defensive position. Obviously if O'hanlon was fit he would start. I think Ifil would probably benefit from a bit of experience on either side, therefore the above would be my starting formation. You've chosen my line up. Now I understand what's behind the 4:5:1, he wanted to make use of Whalley. If he really must play Whalley, put him on the left instead of Nicolau for the first half. I would certainly give Thorpe a half, especially if Roberts isn't opening his legs and showing his class. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: DiV on Monday, September 5, 2005, 20:56:33 Quote from: "Whits" i bet we play 4-5-1 :D If he does..... I'll go fucking mental 4-5-1 at home is stupid Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: sonicyouth on Monday, September 5, 2005, 20:57:22 If we play 4-5-1 against Southend I'm going to just put "bollocks" up on the scoreboard, leave it and go home/to the pub.
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: DiV on Monday, September 5, 2005, 21:08:14 Quote from: "sonicyouth" If we play 4-5-1 against Southend I'm going to just put "bollocks" up on the scoreboard, leave it and go home/to the pub. Also put, DV85 for manager! and 4-4-2 and Christian Roberts Title: Re: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Crozzer on Monday, September 5, 2005, 21:22:34 Quote from: "Walrus" Mine is: Code: Heaton Subs: Bulman Collins Whalley Cureton Shakes This would be my team with the assumption taken that O'Hanlon and Evans are out through injury. I'd like to see Thorpe given another chance, with Roberts playing but currently I just don't see their being room for him up front. It's a shame to drop Heath altogether but haven't been overly impressed, and I think Roberts gives us something different on the wing, whilst Nicholau's crossing is quality. Shakes has to play. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Piemonte on Tuesday, September 6, 2005, 11:57:40 KT's selection looks spot on, assuming O'Hanlon is still out.
Walrus, what the fuck are you on? Why does Thorpe deserve to start? His performances and attitude so far in an STFC shirt barely justify being on the bench, let alone the first XI. If he scores a few for the reserves I'd consider giving him another chance, untill that point he can go fuck himself :evil: Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: I 8 Razor on Tuesday, September 6, 2005, 12:25:07 Quote from: "sonicyouth" If we play 4-5-1 against Southend I'm going to just put "bollocks" up on the scoreboard, leave it and go home/to the pub. :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick: Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: OOH! SHAUN TAYLOR on Tuesday, September 6, 2005, 12:39:45 I reckon monkey man will think that the 4-5-1 formation has been such a rip roaring success that he will go one step further and go for a 4-6-0.
Toss pot. Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: DiV on Tuesday, September 6, 2005, 20:22:39 Such a roaring success.....we got 0 points...!
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: walrus on Tuesday, September 6, 2005, 20:36:02 Quote from: "Piemonte" If he scores a few for the reserves I'd consider giving him another chance, untill that point he can go fuck himself :evil: Now what Mr. Pie? After a hat-trick can he now have his chance? Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Crozzer on Wednesday, September 7, 2005, 02:18:21 Thorpe has to start, otherwise just loan him out to Rochdale. Assuming no more 4:5:1, give the guy three starts, if he doesn't do anything then send him on his way. Cureton can take his place if he can't be arsed.
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Barnard on Wednesday, September 7, 2005, 03:27:55 kinky Tom's lineup looks about right, although maybe Cureton for Roberts, as I think Cureton's played quite well without having much luck, and Roberts has been more of a handfull off the bench than starting.
Apart from one smart finish against Oldham, Thorpe has done nothing. Hopefully his hattrick for the reserves may sort him out a bit. Title: Re: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: JMH75 on Wednesday, September 7, 2005, 07:53:17 Quote from: "Kinky Tom" So after all this polling from DV we might as well put down our line up for Saturday. Mine is: Code: Heaton Though we all know Heath will start, and King probably will not go with it, but I'd consider the best option. 100% agree with the formation and 90% with the personnel Tom, good work. :D My only thought would be to maybe have Whalley instead of Pook, Cureton instead of Roberts and Comm Platt featured in the back somewhere as he has looked pretty good when i've seen him. I would be more than happy with the team above but I can see King playing 4-5-1 again, if not he won't pick Nicolau in front of Heath. :( Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: Piemonte on Wednesday, September 7, 2005, 11:05:53 Quote from: "Walrus" Quote from: "Piemonte" If he scores a few for the reserves I'd consider giving him another chance, untill that point he can go fuck himself :evil: Now what Mr. Pie? After a hat-trick can he now have his chance? NO :mrgreen: Title: Re: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: normy on Thursday, September 8, 2005, 14:39:25 Quote from: "Kinky Tom" So after all this polling from DV we might as well put down our line up for Saturday. Mine is: Code: Heaton Though we all know Heath will start, and King probably will not go with it, but I'd consider the best option. The most attacking lineup in my view and hope we go with it, to make it worth missing the test cricket ! :run: Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: adje on Thursday, September 8, 2005, 20:24:59 Am I in a minority that thinks Jenkins should be in the side.Not only that -he should be capt.
Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: DiV on Thursday, September 8, 2005, 20:25:55 Quote from: "adje" Am I in a minority that thinks Jenkins should be in the side.Not only that -he should be capt. Yes, mainly because he isnt really match fit at the moment. Captain, nah I'd have our longest serving and most energetic player as Captain.....Stefani WOOOOOOOOOOOOOAH Title: Might as well do the formation too then... Post by: mexico red on Thursday, September 8, 2005, 20:30:27 jenkins for right back captain and manager i love jenkins his kit is skill.
|