Thetownend.com

25% => Players => Topic started by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 10:58:06



Title: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 10:58:06
Quote -    ELLIOT Benyon’s desire to play at a higher level and the lack of a guarantee of first-team football contributed to his loan move to Wycombe, interim Town chairman Jeremy Wray has revealed.

Is this yet another Premiership Wannabee who thinks he's much better than he is  ????, at 23 if he was that great he would be setting the stage alight by now.
Seems that yet another player we've invested in is just using us as a stepping stone, thinking that he is much better than he actually is.
He needs to have a good look at himself and remember No player at any club is guaranteed first-team football, you have to earn the right.

What will happen at the end of next season when the loan term runs out ??, assuming (hopefully) we are promoted and Wycombe are relegated will he be back with his tail between your legs pleading his undying devotion to the Town again ??.
You've had your chance, face facts, you just were not good enough, Obviously Di canio feels the same way,  if you'd been that good we'd still be in League 1.

You were quick enough to accept the deal, if you think the pressure here is too much for you then think again, you will be in the same postion next season as you were last season.

OK - I agree, maybe you did'nt have that many first team opportunities but 1 goal in the 12 games you had does not make you a candidate for first-team football.

I'm keeping an open mind on this one, not sure if his return would be welcome, but I've a feeling this won't happen anyway.



Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Zippy on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:00:36
I agree. Greedy twat.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Arriba on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:02:02
If the club were interested in keeping him,do you honestly believe they would loan him out for a season?
He has been here a few months,cost a fee and is under contract. If he was rated he wouldn't be loaned out. Even if he wanted out he would be sold on, as is the norm.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Ardiles on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:04:27
Footballers are professionals with career aspirations just like anyone else.  He was scoring prolifically for Torquay during the first half of last season, and probably felt he had earned the right for a shot at a higher level.  So he moved to us.

Having moved, it didn't work out.  He got injured and never had a chance to make his mark when Wilson was here.  By the time Hart arrived, the ship was practically sunk already.  Would he feel any loyalty to STFC?  Very much doubt it.  If I was him, I would probably be doing something similar.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Batch on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:05:48
Quote
Quote -    ELLIOT Benyon’s desire to play at a higher level and the lack of a guarantee of first-team football...

I think this says it all. If he was looking likely to be a bench warmer then why wouldn't he move?! He has my sympathy. It just didn't work out here what with Wilson getting the chop then the injury then Hart.

To me this signals that PDC must have a couple of strikers lined up who he think are better than Benyon.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Trashbat? on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:10:34
When your the only forward on a teams books and they cant guarentee you first team football, it would seem to speak volumes about what they think of your ability.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: magicroundabout on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:13:26
When your the only forward on a teams books and they cant guarentee you first team football, it would seem to speak volumes about what they think of your ability.

this


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: thedarkprince on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 11:59:52
When your the only forward on a teams books and they cant guarentee you first team football, it would seem to speak volumes about what they think of your ability.

Or you plan to play a 4-6-0 formation.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Whits on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 12:00:36
Or you plan to play a 4-6-0 formation.

is paul hart coming back?!


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 13:55:13
is paul hart coming back?!
No.. no...no.............Please No............................................ :(


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 13:56:43
If the club were interested in keeping him,do you honestly believe they would loan him out for a season?
He has been here a few months,cost a fee and is under contract. If he was rated he wouldn't be loaned out. Even if he wanted out he would be sold on, as is the norm.
If the club were interested in keeping him,do you honestly believe they would loan him out for a season?
He has been here a few months,cost a fee and is under contract. If he was rated he wouldn't be loaned out. Even if he wanted out he would be sold on, as is the norm.
Exactly what I am saying......not that good.............Another waste of money.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Spencer_White on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 17:46:29
I dont think Di Canio thinks he's any good.

You never know, he might bang them in for Wycombe and STFC get back more than what they paid for him. Could happen.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: oxford_fan on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 18:45:19
When your the only forward on a teams books and they cant guarentee you first team football, it would seem to speak volumes about what they think of your ability.
but when you consider that he's gone a league above to start regularly, and that last season he scored regularly in L2, then maybe someone's been a bit hasty, stupid even, in their assessment of your ability.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Costanza on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 18:54:00
The guy is from Wycombe, he wants to play in L1 and wasn't penciled in to lead the Town attack. It's a no brainer, no point having a player mope on the bench.

Perhaps it's because I didn't rate him pre-joining but I really don't regard this as puzzling in any way.

Did Benyon deserve a chance at Swindon? Absolutely. However it's not worked out, it happens... esecially when a player is brought in and the man who signs him leaves weeks later.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 18:57:53
but when you consider that he's gone a league above to start regularly, and that last season he scored regularly in L2, then maybe someone's been a bit hasty, stupid even, in their assessment of your ability.
I think we are better off waiting until the end of the season before we determain that. No one has even said that was the case infact he was only told he can't be promised a starting place which is what every manager does isn't it? He was asked like every other player if he wants to stay and fight for his place and has obviously decided against it so fuck him.

Where he is a new manager i think too many are looking to jump on him at every opportunity here. 99% of us were happy to get rid of nearly every one of these players at some point and now we are people are panicking.

Benyon no matter how people try and cover it up has had 1 and a half decent seasons in league2 and is hardly proven.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: leefer on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 19:02:30
I think we are better off waiting until the end of the season before we determain that. No one has even said that was the case infact he was only told he can't be promised a starting place which is what every manager does isn't it? He was asked like every other player if he wants to stay and fight for his place and has obviously decided against it so fuck him.

Where he is a new manager i think too many are looking to jump on him at every opportunity here. 99% of us were happy to get rid of nearly every one of these players at some point and now we are people are panicking.

Benyon no matter how people try and cover it up has had 1 and a half decent seasons in league2 and is hardly proven.

Agree,we gave him a chance to step up,granted he was fucked around a bit but staying and helping the cause wasn't an option for him by the looks.
Fact is it was widely known the Town were happy to cut there losses on him but seems that apart from Wycombe no one else was interested.


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 19:19:20
I think we are better off waiting until the end of the season before we determain that. No one has even said that was the case infact he was only told he can't be promised a starting place which is what every manager does isn't it? He was asked like every other player if he wants to stay and fight for his place and has obviously decided against it so fuck him.

Where he is a new manager i think too many are looking to jump on him at every opportunity here. 99% of us were happy to get rid of nearly every one of these players at some point and now we are people are panicking.

Benyon no matter how people try and cover it up has had 1 and a half decent seasons in league2 and is hardly proven.
I am in no way blaming Di Canio - most players underperformed last season, just like this one so, as you say - fuck him  -  Another waste of money !!!!!


Title: Re: Elliot Benyon - Another waste of money ???????
Post by: swindonmaniac on Wednesday, June 22, 2011, 19:21:30
I dont think Di Canio thinks he's any good.

You never know, he might bang them in for Wycombe and STFC get back more than what they paid for him. Could happen.
Lets hope !!!!!!!!!!!!!