Title: Derren Brown Post by: Whits on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 21:45:11 Anyone watching tonights show?
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Simon Pieman on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 21:47:30 Yeah I am. It's keeping me amused but it has to be fake or what they'll do at the end will be. Why are the plane engines on already?
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Freddies Ferret on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 21:48:22 weird as fuck....that guy is one shit actor
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: LucienSanchez on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:02:00 Hmmmm... i always watch these, and every time it seems massively fake and gets on my tits.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Freddies Ferret on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:07:47 i just cant see how its real
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Freddies Ferret on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:12:23 nice bird he's got there :)
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Simon Pieman on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:14:41 I think people who try and decide if it's real or not miss the point.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Freddies Ferret on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:18:48 surely that is the whole point though? deciding if it's real or not
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Samdy Gray on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:21:15 His shows have always been about sub-consciously influencing the audience to somehow change or better their lives. Like Si said, it's never really supposed to be about whether it's real or fake, it's all about the (not so) hidden message.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: @MacPhlea on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:28:36 His shows have always been about sub-consciously influencing the audience to somehow change or better their lives. Like Si said, it's never really supposed to be about whether it's real or fake, it's all about the (not so) hidden message. What he said... The 'aircraft' was landed a Gatwick, a cat 1 airport where you can 'land' hands free in a pea souper - a manitee could have landed that plane but it's the fact he got off his arse and was prepared to do it even though he was shit scared of flying... Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Simon Pieman on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 22:44:36 With Derren's shows there are large elements of things not being real or maybe even the whole concept itself.
Like the show when the old biddy becomes good at poker in a week. Did she play in a real tournament? Did she have more than one week's practice? Was she an experienced poker player acting the part of a clueless old biddy? Indeed, the tricks could even be the same as the treats and it doesn't matter what they 'randomly' select. It's just like watching magic tricks and coming up with theories as to how it's done, entertaining at the same time. I think the recent shows are so far fetched they aren't meant to make you think how it's done but just emphasise a point. Like the lottery show, got you caught up in the buzz that he was going to predict the lottery numbers then basically pissed on that theory. He's telling you that you can't have a system for random lotteries or Deal or No Deal. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Spy on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 23:03:46 I think he is an extremely clever bloke with a great understanding of psychology and that was best shown in his older stuff like when he made the bloke believe that he could rob the suitcase of money from the securicor van.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 23:07:21 I must admit i've always preferred his series as opposed to the one off "specials" that he does. Mostly the earlier series as well although Trick or Treat was alright too.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: flammableBen on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 23:19:29 I'm not a fan who's watched all his stuff religiously, and missed tonights because I was watching whatever Shane Meadows film it was which was on.
From what I have seen though I think his best stuff is when he does something not to out there but impressive, then offers an explanation, and then 5 mins later you think "well that would have been a clever way of doing it, but you probably did it in an easier more staged way". I think stuff like the lottery last year was a step too far on that, as his explanation on how he could have rigged the lottery was nonsense, as was all the filler gap bits about the power of the people finding patterns in the numbers. Vague memory of him stopping everybody standing up or something? That works quite well because they'll be enough nutters out their claiming they couldn't. Can't really remember how the show went though because I think I was drunk when I watched it. Didn't he do something when he made some bird win 7 horse race bets in a row or something? Then he claimed out he'd got 30,000 people to try the same thing (or whatever the odds worked out as, was she betting favourites?). Then you think that he can't have filmed them all so he probably just faked horse race video streams in a few bookies in a deal with ladbrookes or something. Can't remember that one too well so might have got it a bit wrong. I dunno, I'll watch it if there's nothing else on but I think the bigger the stunt, then the more the rational explanation suffers. Even if the rational explanation bit is fake, it's a big part of the enjoyment, and just as much a part of the whole illusion. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: flammableBen on Wednesday, September 8, 2010, 23:25:02 Jesus, I haven't written hundreds of words of bollocks on something I know very little about for fucking ages. I need more TEF time.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Simon Pieman on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 00:02:46 I agree with Ben.
just to add my opinion of the show - it was weak Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: magicroundabout on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 06:42:12 never watched last night but went to see him live at his Enigma tour which is being shown on TV in the Autum.
Having seen him live all i can say is the blokes is clever as fuck and the tricks he does are amazing. Selecting people out of the audiance is completly random and not once did i think they were actors. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Barry Scott on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 06:53:36 All I will add is of course it's real and the bloke's a genius. I wanted to write a load of bollocks justifying why, but then decided I don't care. :)
I loved the show for the record. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Melksham Red on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 07:17:33 I wanted to write a load of bollocks justifying why, but then decided I don't care. :) Same as that but for the opposite reason. I have never watched him before but gave it a chance last night because of missus nagging. I thought it was a complete load of fake shite, poorly performed by shit actors. About as influencial and empowering as watching a load of fake shite, poorly performed by shit actors. Definately a show for the women. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Jamiesfuturewife on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 07:32:24 It started off OK but then really annoyed me!! Like if he was that shy and stuff why would he even apply to go on a gameshow??!
And the bit when he organised that party! God I did a bit of sick In my mouth - the thing that annoyed me most was the fact he wore the same clothes EVER day?????! Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: matt_jada on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 10:18:37 was it just me, but i was convinced that when the plane took off it was mid afternoon and sunny flying to jersey an hour away.
however later when he thought he was landing the plane it was pitch black, surely he must of realised something wasnt right. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Jimmy Glass is an Alien on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 10:36:08 I must admit i've always preferred his series as opposed to the one off "specials" that he does. Mostly the earlier series as well although Trick or Treat was alright too. I'd have to agree. I wouldn't mind seeing him live at the Wyvern or something, but the 'specials' do seem rather staged and far fetched. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Ben Wah Balls on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 11:17:55 I just rewatched the one with the granny playing poker and I think that one was probably the least impressive one he's done. I don't actually doubt that she'd never really played poker before but she didn't do anything that showed she had suddenly got good anyway. They were playing a 6 player sit and go starting with 2000 chips and 25/50 blinds with the blinds going up quickly - in that format even some who barely knows the rules has at least a 10% chance of winning even if they're playing the top 5 players in the world and about a 15 to 20% chance of finishing in the top two. The commentators were making out it would be difficult for her to last 10 minutes but that's just nonsense, she could just fold every hand and last longer than that.
They also said she was playing against 5 of the best players in the UK but in reality the only ones who were at all well known were Neil Channing and Nik Persaud and some of the others probably aren't even winning players. That doesn't really make that much difference anyway though because in one 40 hand tournament it's going to mainly be about who gets the luckiest. In the first hand they showed, Nik was all in on the flop with two overcards and a queen high flush draw and they suggested she had some kind of tell he was weak and was trying to scare the other players but his hand isn't that weak and rarely in particularly bad shape, she called all in and won with a king high flush draw which is one of the only hands that's a decent favourite over him. That is just extremely lucky and you really don't need to be good at poker to make that call. Second hand a player shoved his small blind with t7o and she called with K9s. That was the only hand they showed that I believe anything Derren taught her would have actually helped as the player did look like he didn't want a call but he seemed to be extremely short-stacked anyway which means it's a trivially easy call and she was only a slight favourite anyway so it's lucky to win. In the final hand she lost with AQ v 99 when most of the money seemed to go in preflop and there was an ace on the flop and a nine on the turn. Those were the only hands they showed and they suggested she'd been really unlucky to finish second but really she was quite lucky in those hands and almost anyone could have made the top two with the same luck. The programme just took advantage of the fact that most people don't realise that the results of one poker tournament are pretty meaningless and it's only long term results that matter. If they played the same tournament a few hundred times and she was in the top two the majority of the times then it would mean something. I thought the one he did yesterday was one of his best though and they are always entertaining. I noticed the simulator they used was a CTC one, which is the same as a friend of mine used when he was doing his pilot training in Nursling near Southampton, so they must have landed at Southampton airport and not Jersey. Triseros is right about anyone being able to do the landing, my mate said that it's a Boeing 737-800 simulator and one of the best in the world but the plane was already stabilised and on an auto-land approach so it would have pretty much landed itself once he disconnected the autopilot, apart from the flare which he didn't do properly anyway. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Simon Pieman on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 12:55:19 Tell you what though, stick me in a 737 and tell me it's going to crash unless I land it and I would be shitting it despite how easy it is.
Which makes sense, the show's aim was not to make him perform super-heroics but get over that initial 'oh shit I can't do this' stage and get the courage up to do something which turned out to be not as bad as expected. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Barry Scott on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 13:07:29 Tell you what though, stick me in a 737 and tell me it's going to crash unless I land it and I would be shitting it despite how easy it is. Which makes sense, the show's aim was not to make him perform super-heroics but get over that initial 'oh shit I can't do this' stage and get the courage up to do something which turned out to be not as bad as expected. Exactly, which was why I thought it was good. And I used to have a fetish for reading popular psychology and NLP! (You could see various Pattern Interrupts, which were what really came to reshape him by breaking his habit and routine.) The end result didn't involve any tricks, as such, just reprogramming of the subconscious. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Benzel on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 15:55:50 I enjoyed it. He's changed that blokes life for the better too.
Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Dr Pierre Chang on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 17:28:35 In my mouth - the thing that annoyed me most was the fact he wore the same clothes EVER day?????! Haha he liked his G-Star stuff didn't he?Thought it was alright, enjoyable watch. Title: Re: Derren Brown Post by: Batch on Thursday, September 9, 2010, 19:35:24 Thought this was pretty shit myself. Better than his "the Events" though.
Shame, because his stage stuff and older TV stuff was brilliant. |