Thetownend.com

80% => The Nevillew General Discussion Forum => Topic started by: Chubbs on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:07:27



Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Chubbs on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:07:27
I dont normally do these chain letter things but i actualy think this one can work, and i will be participating in it.
I got this sent in an email, so post it around, email it to people etc etc.

See what you think and pass it on if you agree with it

Quote
We are hitting £123.9 a litre in some areas now, soon we will be faced with paying £2.00 a ltr. Philip Hollsworth offered this good idea:

This makes MUCH MORE SENSE than the 'don't buy petrol on a certain   day campaign that was going around last April or May! The oil companies just laughed at that because they knew we wouldn't  
continue to hurt ourselves by refusing to buy petrol. It was more of an inconvenience to us than it was a problem for them. BUT,whoever
thought of this idea, has come up with a plan that can really work.

Please read it and join in!

Now that the oil companies and the OPEC nations have conditioned us  to think that the cost of a litre is CHEAP, we need to take  aggressive action to teach them that BUYERS control the market place
not sellers. With the price of petrol going up more each day, we  consumers need to take action. The only way we are going to see the  price of petrol come down is if we hit someone in the pocket by not
purchasing their Petrol! And we can do that WITHOUT hurting ourselves. Here's the idea:

For the rest of this year DON'T purchase ANY petrol from the two biggest oil companies (which now are one), ESSO and BP.


If they are not selling any petrol, they will be inclined to reduce their prices. If they reduce their prices, the other companies will have to follow suit. But to have an impact we need to reach literally millions of Esso and BP petrol buyers. It's really simple to do!!

Now, don't wimp out at this point... keep reading and I'll explain how simple it is to reach millions of people!!

I am sending this note to a lot of people. If each of you send it  to  at least ten more (30 x 10 = 300)... and those 300 send it to at  least ten more (300 x 10 = 3,000) ... and so on, by the time the
message reaches the sixth generation of people, we will have reached  over THREE MILLION consumers! If those three million get excited and
pass this on to ten friends each, then 30 million people will have been contacted! If it goes one level further, you guessed it... ..

THREE HUNDRED MILLION PEOPLE!!!

Again, all You have to do is send this to 10 people. That's all.(and  not buy at ESSO/BP) How long would all that take? If each of us  sends this email out to ten more people within one day of receipt,
all 300 MILLION people could conceivably be contacted within the  next 8days!!! Acting together we can make a difference . If this makes
sense to you, please pass this message on.

PLEASE HOLD OUT UNTIL THEY LOWER THEIR PRICES TO THE 69p a LITRE   RANGE  

It's easy to make this happen. Just forward this email, and buy your  petrol at Shell, Asda,Tesco, Sainsburys, Morrisons Jet etc. i.e.  boycott BP and Esso


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: lebowski on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:15:09
Well ESSO (Exon) provide Tesco's forecourts with fuel, and BP provide Sainsbury's.

So in summary, that thing is total bollards.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: lebowski on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:17:20
Also, forecourts make hardly any money at all from petrol, they'll make more from selling mars bars than a tank full of unleaded. The petrol company's obscene profits come from elsewhere.

Your revolution is over Chubbs.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Nemo on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:17:46
Original Sender: [email protected]


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Fred Elliot on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:24:26
Quote from: "Nemo"
Original Sender: [email protected]


 :mrgreen:  :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Chubbs on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:27:46
ahh well, i never buy from esso or BP anyway, so nevermind.  :D


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: ronnie21 on Monday, May 19, 2008, 19:58:08
What is this PERTOL!!  I fill up at Tesco and they call it petrol!!


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Batch on Monday, May 19, 2008, 20:08:11
I think they tried something similar with Esso just after the big protests. It was a good idea but didn't work.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: reeves4england on Monday, May 19, 2008, 22:33:40
It's not going to work. End of argument.

And 69p per litre? You are joking right?!


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Chubbs on Monday, May 19, 2008, 23:47:30
Quote from: "reeves4england"
It's not going to work. End of argument.

And 69p per litre? You are joking right?!


where was the start?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Monday, May 19, 2008, 23:48:42
Quote
We are hitting £123.9 a litre in some areas now

123 quid a litre, f**k me, I thought £1.11 was pricey!

Erm and why would you send it to 300m people when the population of the UK (including babies etc who I'm guessing don't buy a shitload of petrol, or have much access to email come to that) is only around 60m.

And the thing others have pointed out - that half the "alternatives" the bloke recommends are supplied by the big two anyway. Does he think Tesco make their own petrol? At petrol farms presumably?

Might seem picky but if this "anonymous campaigner" can't get the basics right, it rather undermines any basic credibility of the whole thing. Which is why I'd be sending this straight to my spam folder along with all the other chain mail spams I get. Why do these people bother?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: flammableBen on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 06:55:19
Why don't people just stop moaning and drink white ace instead? That's still at 96p a litre.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Sippo on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 07:16:48
Get this. Tesco had their diesel at £1.20 per litre at the start of the day, come 4pm it was £1.22 a litre!  :x


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Ralphy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 07:21:17
I thought Shell was the biggest oil company in the world? Not Esso and BP?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: DMR on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 07:49:21
Petrol's simply not going to go down, this happened before and will happen again... we cannot do without so we're duty bound to pay whatever they like.

My old man was telling me years ago when people protested it simply resulted in the prices going up again, as if to prove a point!


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: herthab on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:00:10
It's not the fuel companies that take the biggest cut anyway, it's the cunting taxman.

Probably to subsidise the sweaties..............................


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Arnold.J.Rimmer on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:02:56
Not sure if anyone has driven past Bridge Garage in Marlborough (UK's most expensive) recently, somebody has spray painted "BULL SHIT" right accross the price sign.  :D


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: tans on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:10:09
:Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Samdy Gray on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:24:41
Quote from: "lebowski"
The petrol company's obscene profits come from elsewhere.


It's cunning financial engineering. In effect, one part of the company 'sells' the oil to another part of the company or something like that.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Peter Venkman on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:25:51
Fucking £1.29.9 in Chard Tescos for Disiesel bloody disgusting.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:31:58
Quote from: "DMR"
My old man was telling me years ago when people protested it simply resulted in the prices going up again, as if to prove a point!

Simple law of supply and demand. If no-one buys from X and Y, then more people will be buying from A and B. As the demand increases, A and B put their prices up. And to rub salt into the wound, A and B likely do not have the supply to meet the demand so have to buy in oil from X and Y's refinery. So you end up paying more AND increasing X and Y's profits.

Oh, and the original post is just a variant of a widely known chain mail that's been doing the rounds since about 2000:

http://www.snopes.com/politics/gasoline/gasout.asp

And there's even a "boycott women who don't dress revealingly enough" variant. Which is equally likely to succeed.

http://www.all-lies.com/legends/protest/gaswar.shtml


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: DMR on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 08:59:10
Quote from: "pauld"
Quote from: "DMR"
My old man was telling me years ago when people protested it simply resulted in the prices going up again, as if to prove a point!

Simple law of supply and demand. If no-one buys from X and Y, then more people will be buying from A and B. As the demand increases, A and B put their prices up. And to rub salt into the wound, A and B likely do not have the supply to meet the demand so have to buy in oil from X and Y's refinery. So you end up paying more AND increasing X and Y's profits.

Oh, and the original post is just a variant of a widely known chain mail that's been doing the rounds since about 2000:

http://www.snopes.com/politics/gasoline/gasout.asp

And there's even a "boycott women who don't dress revealingly enough" variant. Which is equally likely to succeed.

http://www.all-lies.com/legends/protest/gaswar.shtml


That's what I meant but I figured my way was more concise ;)


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Lumps on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 10:29:02
I love the way that people who are ususally enthusiastic supporters of the free market, suddenly turn when the impact of supply and demand takes a bit out of their disposable income.

It's capitalism I'm afraid. It's always worked like this and always will. You're looking at a constantly diminishing resource that's becoming more and more difficult to find and extract. Add to that the markets natural tendency toward monopoly, particularly in fields with major barriers to market entry like the oil industry, which leads to a small number of suppliers who can ruthlessly exploit fluctuations in global prices to smuggle in increases in profit.

So why the hell are you suprised that this stuff is getting more expensive?

Some of you people have to make up your minds. Either the free market is the best way to control the supply of goods and services to market or it isn't. You might not always agree with my politics but at least I'm fucking consistent


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Colin Todd on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 10:47:27
Thats all well and good lumps, if you ignore how much of the UK petrol price is made up of tax (and VAT on the fucking tax!)

The government are recieving a several billion a year windfall as the result of higher oil prices. They could do something to lower the tax burden and keep prices at a more reaonable (albeit still increasing for the reasons you have stated) level. They wont.

And whys that? Because our wonderful socialist goverment has spent far far too much money and desperatly needs the tax income. Despite increasing the tax burden on an average working man by an enormous amount in the last 12 years, with a negligible improvement on anything.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:19:20
Quote from: "Lumps"
I love the way that people who are ususally enthusiastic supporters of the free market, suddenly turn when the impact of supply and demand takes a bit out of their disposable income.

It's capitalism I'm afraid. It's always worked like this and always will. You're looking at a constantly diminishing resource that's becoming more and more difficult to find and extract. Add to that the markets natural tendency toward monopoly, particularly in fields with major barriers to market entry like the oil industry, which leads to a small number of suppliers who can ruthlessly exploit fluctuations in global prices to smuggle in increases in profit.

So why the hell are you suprised that this stuff is getting more expensive?

Some of you people have to make up your minds. Either the free market is the best way to control the supply of goods and services to market or it isn't. You might not always agree with my politics but at least I'm fucking consistent
That is a cracking post it is just unfortunate that it is bollocks.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: herthab on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:22:43
Quote from: "Lumps"
I love the way that people who are ususally enthusiastic supporters of the free market, suddenly turn when the impact of supply and demand takes a bit out of their disposable income.

It's capitalism I'm afraid. It's always worked like this and always will. You're looking at a constantly diminishing resource that's becoming more and more difficult to find and extract. Add to that the markets natural tendency toward monopoly, particularly in fields with major barriers to market entry like the oil industry, which leads to a small number of suppliers who can ruthlessly exploit fluctuations in global prices to smuggle in increases in profit.

So why the hell are you suprised that this stuff is getting more expensive?

Some of you people have to make up your minds. Either the free market is the best way to control the supply of goods and services to market or it isn't. You might not always agree with my politics but at least I'm fucking consistent


You manage to appear both intelligent and a fuckwit with this post.

Well done.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:30:29
Its a way of life, if you dont like it go on public transport.

I fill up about twice a week at £70 a pop, I do not like it but I cant change it


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Lumps on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:34:27
Quote from: "Colin Todd"


And whys that? Because our wonderful socialist goverment has spent far far too much money and desperatly needs the tax income. Despite increasing the tax burden on an average working man by an enormous amount in the last 12 years, with a negligible improvement on anything.


You kind of give yourself away a bit at the end there don't you? Not that it wasn't all a bit Daily Mail before then, but having to call politicians you don't like "socialist", despite all the evidence to the contrary, including the stuff you bring up in your own arguement, is a bit of a giveaway.

There's nothing socialist about this government and deep down you know it. It's in the shit because it's pursued the same kind of half-arsed monatarist one minute, keynsianist the next economic policies so beloved of the every british government since the war, including those led by the Lady Thatcher. Yes it has increased the tax burden on the average working man, whilst at the same time it's lowered taxes for industry and commerce and the wealthy. Just like every government since Harold Wilson's.

Oh and the fuel tax? Have a look back and see which government introduced the fuel tax escalator. Proposing to put up fuel duty by 3% above the rate of inflation in each budget that it was in power. Seriously, do you think that a re-elected Major government would have abandoned that policy and cut fuel duty and the other tax burdens that you're complaining about?

If you want to blame everything that's wrong with the British economy and society on a bogieman like "socialism" rather than actually looking at the economic policies that governments have pursued then that's fine by me, but you're not going to be able to muster a particularly convincing argument are you.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Lumps on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:37:55
Hey Don and Herthab.

Brilliant counter arguments. Very incisive. You should both be on question time.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: herthab on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:41:25
Cheers.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: herthab on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:43:19
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
Its a way of life, if you dont like it go on public transport.

I fill up about twice a week at £70 a pop, I do not like it but I cant change it


No disrespect Ash, but that post sums up the Great British public to a tee.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 11:51:15
Quote from: "Lumps"
Hey Don and Herthab.

Brilliant counter arguments. Very incisive. You should both be on question time.
Well you are on a Football Forum i suggest if it is good counter arguments you want then you should get on question time.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:02:45
Quote from: "herthab"
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
Its a way of life, if you dont like it go on public transport.

I fill up about twice a week at £70 a pop, I do not like it but I cant change it


No disrespect Ash, but that post sums up the Great British public to a tee.
Agree totally, thats why it shouldnt matter I vote BNP


(joke lumps)


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:06:38
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Quote from: "Lumps"
Hey Don and Herthab.

Brilliant counter arguments. Very incisive. You should both be on question time.
Well you are on a Football Forum i suggest if it is good counter arguments you want then you should get on question time.

You haven't watched Question Time lately have you?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:07:33
Every thursday :oops:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:13:56
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Every thursday :oops:

 :shock: And I thought I was sad!

FWIW, I'd be inclined to say both Lumps and Colin are right - while the rise may be down to market forces, the fact it hurts so much is because petrol prices are so high in the first place which is due to the huge amount of tax on petrol in this country. But that's not uniquely down to the current government although whichever government is in power is going to get blamed for it (and rightly so - they could change it if they wanted to). And to describe New Labour as in any way "socialist" is simply laughable.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: herthab on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:15:01
I used to avidly watch Question Time when Robin Day was the host. Watched intermittently since, but it's all bollocks. Politicians just avoid answering questions and try and deflect any blame onto rival parties.

And there's not enough bow ties on it now either........


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:16:42
Quote from: "pauld"
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Every thursday :oops:

 :shock: And I thought I was sad!

FWIW, I'd be inclined to say both Lumps and Colin are right - while the rise may be down to market forces, the fact it hurts so much is because petrol prices are so high in the first place which is due to the huge amount of tax on petrol in this country. But that's not uniquely down to the current government although whichever government is in power is going to get blamed for it (and rightly so - they could change it if they wanted to). And to describe New Labour as in any way "socialist" is simply laughable.
Oh you are  :D

I tried to get tickets for bristol the other week and they did not even reply believe me that dimblebollox got a abusive email


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:21:19
'My names Dean, I wanna know what your doing to make beer and pies cheaper'

followed by

'Make Poverty History...Cheaper drugs now'


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:26:48
I wanted to make valid points actually so fuck you

*that is not a bite*


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:42:30
You cant afford to fuck me.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:57:17
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Oh you are  :D

:D Kind of walked right into that didn't I? Good catch.

Quote
I tried to get tickets for bristol the other week and they did not even reply believe me that dimblebollox got a abusive email

Apparently they put them all on Ticketmaster


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 12:59:24
I wanted to make a point to the education minister

I believe that you can judge a teenager’s potential between the ages of 14- 16 yrs old so why would it not be beneficial for kids of this age to be doing 2 days a week employment for a company. For example a lad of 14 who is bottom of every class could be given the chance to work as a plumber gaining two years experience instead of  failing every exam not qualifying for college and then doing fuckall with his life because he has constantly been told he is not good enough at something.

If you tell people from an early age that they are not as good as other people all the time 9/10 of them will end up doing fuckall with their lives

(I would not have sworn if david had asked me though)

And Bushey stop being so immature


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Power to people on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:02:26
Fucking hell how did this thread go from complaining about Petrol Prices to Question Time.....I blame Paul D for his reasoned explanations  :soapy tit wank:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:11:25
Quote from: "Power to people"
Fucking hell how did this thread go from complaining about Petrol Prices to Question Time.....I blame Paul D for his reasoned explanations  :soapy tit wank:

Not me, it's DRS and his intellectual political arguments. I only wanted to have a go at the chainmail spammers. Or at least see if anyone did believe the spam, if they were sufficiently worried about petrol going to £123.9 per litre that I could sell them a few litres at the bargain "Beat the price rises" special discount rate of only £105 a litre.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Colin Todd on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:18:48
Lumps, not everyone with views to the right of yours in automatically a Daily Mail reader. I wouldnt read that sensationalist ignorant bollocks if you paid me.

And as for analysis of the goverments taxation policies, it is where I get the label socialist from.  Yeah, Labour have changed, yeah, they have moved to the centre ground a lot. We all know they had to because they were a fucking unelectable joke. But the still are the party of tax and spend, tax and spend, the party of big goverment.  I'd be less fucked off with them if the country was in a better state for all the extra money they take off me.

Also please tell us how you would re-arrange the global oil market without the use of capitalist policies?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:21:36
Quote from: "Colin Todd"
And as for analysis of the goverments taxation policies, it is where I get the label socialist from.

What like the 10p tax band thing? Massively redistributive that wasn't it? Well, from the working poor to the middle classes it was. Tax and spend they may be, but they are not and never have been socialist.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Colin Todd on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:36:52
Quote from: "pauld"
Quote from: "Colin Todd"
And as for analysis of the goverments taxation policies, it is where I get the label socialist from.

What like the 10p tax band thing? Massively redistributive that wasn't it? Well, from the working poor to the middle classes it was. Tax and spend they may be, but they are not and never have been socialist.


Yes they dropped a giant election losing bollock there, that frankly made no sense at all - but they've not gone after the working classes for the last 10 years have they?  

Working tax credits and other such bollocks -we tax you, then employ hundreds of civil servants in order to calculate how much we give back - are aimed excalty at the working classes.

Fair enough - maybe socailist is the wrong word. I'm struggling to know what the right one is. Wankers?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Arriba on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:37:14
tax on petrol has always been high.it's not suddenly gone through the roof.
the cost of oil barrels is the reason its going up like it is at the moment.
 makes no difference whatsoever who governs the country.
all the finacial shit our country is in cannot really be blamed on labour.its stuff going on around the world thats hitting home here too


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: tans on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:37:20
Lumps and Colin =  8)


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: reeves4england on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:42:22
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
For example a lad of 14 who is bottom of every class could be given the chance to work as a plumber gaining two years experience instead of  failing every exam not qualifying for college and then doing fuckall with his life because he has constantly been told he is not good enough at something.


There are already initiatives in place where kids can go and work 1, 2, 3 or 4 days a week and go into school for the rest. The school then monitors them and makes sure it is working out ok for them, and it gives them some sort of chance to get qualifications at the same time. Even if it is just a small number of scraped GCSEs, it might help in future.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:45:33
Quote from: "reeves4england"
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
For example a lad of 14 who is bottom of every class could be given the chance to work as a plumber gaining two years experience instead of  failing every exam not qualifying for college and then doing fuckall with his life because he has constantly been told he is not good enough at something.


There are already initiatives in place where kids can go and work 1, 2, 3 or 4 days a week and go into school for the rest. The school then monitors them and makes sure it is working out ok for them, and it gives them some sort of chance to get qualifications at the same time. Even if it is just a small number of scraped GCSEs, it might help in future.

Whether there are or not, I'd still rather hear DRS putting the case on QT than some of the smug wet lettuces they usually have.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Jamiesfuturewife on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:45:35
yep we had someone working at the sports centre who was on a scheme like that


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 13:51:51
Quote from: "Colin Todd"
Quote from: "pauld"
Quote from: "Colin Todd"
And as for analysis of the goverments taxation policies, it is where I get the label socialist from.

What like the 10p tax band thing? Massively redistributive that wasn't it? Well, from the working poor to the middle classes it was. Tax and spend they may be, but they are not and never have been socialist.


Yes they dropped a giant election losing bollock there, that frankly made no sense at all - but they've not gone after the working classes for the last 10 years have they?  

Not done a hell of a lot to help them either. Nor have they gone for any kind of really socialist agenda - e.g. renationalisation etc etc. They've just tinkered at the edges of stuff and called it reform. Oh, and taken several huge leaps towards a police state in the name of "fighting the (imaginary) war on terror". Which is what a Tory government will do as well. We live in a post-ideological age in which politicians seek to be distinguished more by claims to a perceived competence than any compelling vision or even any real pretence at having any serious answers to the problems the country faces.
Quote
Fair enough - maybe socailist is the wrong word. I'm struggling to know what the right one is. Wankers?

Sounds fair to me. I wasn't arguing an ideological point so much as a pedantic one.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:03:33
Too many people getting hung up on the 10p tax rate, the biggest single tax that drives the poor to poverty is the fuel duty tax, doesn't matter if your annual salary is £5000pa or £500000pa, when you roll up at the pumps and pay for your fuel you will pay Westminster approx £70 for every hundred you spend.

Absolutely out of order and we wonder why people are in debt, well its through paying taxes from their well earned money.
Perhaps before Mr Brown & co look at debts in poor countries he should look at the people that he alone has made poor in his own beloved Britain.

Another thing that really gets to me is these people who want the higher earners to pay more tax it is wrong to tax someone more just because they have done well for themselves it is that sort of attitude that is driving the wealthy out of this country.

Rant over


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: janaage on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:11:06
Taxing the higher paid just doesn't work, as the high rate tax payers can get around paying 40p in the pound.  Contributing to pensions for example.  There are ways of mitigating tax, and the rich can pay the people to find ways of doing so.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: pauld on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:26:46
Quote from: "janaage"
Taxing the higher paid just doesn't work, as the high rate tax payers can get around paying 40p in the pound.  Contributing to pensions for example.  There are ways of mitigating tax, and the rich can pay the people to find ways of doing so.

Fat cat


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:39:52
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
I wanted to make a point to the education minister

I believe that you can judge a teenager’s potential between the ages of 14- 16 yrs old so why would it not be beneficial for kids of this age to be doing 2 days a week employment for a company. For example a lad of 14 who is bottom of every class could be given the chance to work as a plumber gaining two years experience instead of  failing every exam not qualifying for college and then doing fuckall with his life because he has constantly been told he is not good enough at something.

If you tell people from an early age that they are not as good as other people all the time 9/10 of them will end up doing fuckall with their lives

(I would not have sworn if david had asked me though)

And Bushey stop being so immature


To be fair I cant even moan at that.  Its a good idea, did you want to be a plumber at 14?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:44:01
No I wanted to be a violent smackhead


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:48:33
Being serious though the problem was I did not know what I wanted to do and by the time I had left school I just went from warehouse to warehouse (all agency shit)

If I had some proper work experience behind me then when I turned 16 I may have had a goal in life


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:50:32
I know what your saying mate, my english teacher made my maths teacher hold me back instead of letting me do what I was good at (numbers) fucking slut

being serious, they should introduice working methods/experience into schools


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: yeo on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 14:55:39
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Being serious though the problem was I did not know what I wanted to do and by the time I had left school I just went from warehouse to warehouse (all agency shit)

If I had some proper work experience behind me then when I turned 16 I may have had a goal in life


yep me to.

infact ive been pretty much doing that for 20 years now :|

trouble  is Ive never known what I want to do,still dont.At least if Id been given some worthwhile skills at school I could be earning decent money for doing a job I hate :mrgreen:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: janaage on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:00:07
It does make sense DRS, I hate to see teachers a waste their time with non-academic types and two push these kind of pupils through exam/lesson after lesson/exam whilst telling them they must get a decent education to do anything in life.

Well a trade is just as important as that.  As long as they have a solid educational foundation, reading writing, maths that kind of thing I don't see a problem getting them out in the work place at an earlier age (limited hours though).


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:02:55
Don’t get me wrong some people are happy doing that and absolutely love doing the job I know people who are working at Smith’s ,Woolworths warehouse and have done for over 20 years and they love it but a lot of them were probably forced into those jobs due to Stupid Gcse grades which have no relevance to what you do when you leave school.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Ralphy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:16:12
To be fair Ash you drive a 3 litre, 6 cyclinder BMW so your weekly fuel bill is bound to be high.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: DMR on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:34:39
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Don’t get me wrong some people are happy doing that and absolutely love doing the job I know people who are working at Smith’s ,Woolworths warehouse and have done for over 20 years and they love it but a lot of them were probably forced into those jobs due to Stupid Gcse grades which have no relevance to what you do when you leave school.


On the flip side that irks me a bit... I'm a bright lad but I'm not especially gifted and I had to work my nuts off all the A's I got, so it fucks me off when people who didn't do as well try and argue they're "stupid" or irrelevant or all the rest of it.

Of course they're relevent, they dictate if you can go into further education, what courses you do if you go into it, what exams you take and thus in turn what you can do at uni, which uni you can go to.

I was an Oxbridge candidate 3 years ago mate- but I got my personal life into a mess and I threw that all away, so I know what I'm on about... and ended up working where I am now, which is fine and I've made a decent fist of it - but now I'm going back to uni in September I really regret not getting the A-level grades I should've done, I never did myself justice for my last 18 months in 6th form and now my prospects will never be quite what they were. So I have to disagree... exams and grades aren't stupid.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: janaage on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:38:15
Quote from: "DMR"
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
Don’t get me wrong some people are happy doing that and absolutely love doing the job I know people who are working at Smith’s ,Woolworths warehouse and have done for over 20 years and they love it but a lot of them were probably forced into those jobs due to Stupid Gcse grades which have no relevance to what you do when you leave school.


On the flip side that irks me a bit... I'm a bright lad but I'm not especially gifted and I had to work my nuts off all the A's I got, so it fucks me off when people who didn't do as well try and argue they're "stupid" or irrelevant or all the rest of it.

Of course they're relevent, they dictate if you can go into further education, what courses you do if you go into it, what exams you take and thus in turn what you can do at uni, which uni you can go to.

I was an Oxbridge candidate 3 years ago mate- but I got my personal life into a mess and I threw that all away, so I know what I'm on about... and ended up working where I am now, which is fine and I've made a decent fist of it - but now I'm going back to uni in September I really regret not getting the A-level grades I should've done, I never did myself justice for my last 18 months in 6th form and now my prospects will never be quite what they were. So I have to disagree... exams and grades aren't stupid.


I don't think that's what he's getting at though Dave.  I think he's saying if you don't have the potential you never are, you may be better suited to a trade rather than education.  By the age of 14 teachers should be able to spot the more educational friendly student, rather than the lads/girls that are biding their time to leave school at the earliest opportunity.

I may have got the wrong end of the stick though.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Arriba on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:45:01
all about timing imo.kids alot of the time dont have a clue or the motivation to think about their futures.
they fail school ,but are not necessarily not capable of gaining results.
i didn't have a clue what i wanted to do.fucked about at school and got shit grades.
in hindsight i wish i knuckled down as i could have done well.and maybe done a apprenticeship or a trade.?

instead for years i stole from shops,got into drugs,and sold a few acid tabs and e's to pay for my weekends.i only got my job because my dad worked there.and prior to that did 2 warehouse jobs which i walked out on.

 not doing well at school can have a negative effect on your future.also people grow up and can make changes and get re-educated later on in life.but people grow up at different ages so thats why we have the situations we have read about in this thread.i have to do the job i do to pay the bills. and dont have the time or money to go back into education.
i fucking regret it big time


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Don Rogers Shop on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:45:54
That is what I am trying to say Dave , tell me what grades are relevant though at school Maths yes of course but that was my poorest grade by a mile I now work in finance so was that relevant? English what the fuck has Shakespear got to do with me getting a job?

I understand that grades are relevant to get onto certain courses that is fine but it is what your are tested on I don’t understand the relevance of


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: BANGKOK RED on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 15:51:38
Which, DMR, I think is the point here.

Yes people like yourself who can do so should go ahead and earn qualifications which will help you in a future career. But the posts above are directed towards non-academic types who would be better of with vocational training rather than academic qualifications, which are unlikely to help them in a factory, work site ect.

I have A-Levels myslef, and yes my qualifications DO help me when going for a job because I work in the finance sector.

However, despite being an academic type I would likely make a USELESS brickie for example, and it is well known that good brickies and people in other skilled trades make a very good wage (Probably more than I do right now)

In short, it's horses for courses mate!


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: ronnie21 on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 16:00:50
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
I know what your saying mate, my english teacher made my maths teacher hold me back instead of letting me do what I was good at (numbers) fucking slut

being serious, they should introduice working methods/experience into schools
Well, BB, your english teacher didn't do much for your spelling!! :wink:


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: BANGKOK RED on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 16:16:23
On another note, I went to school with both David Howells and Jonathon Lewis, to be fair I think that both did well academically but the P.E. Teachers (Mr. Thomas and another one) noticed their talent and encouraged it.

Why can their not be "Teachers" of another category to recognise talents in the "Strugglers"?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Lumps on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 17:11:11
Quote from: Colin Todd

And as for analysis of the goverments taxation policies, it is where I get the label socialist from.  Yeah, Labour have changed, yeah, they have moved to the centre ground a lot. We all know they had to because they were a fucking unelectable joke. But the still are the party of tax and spend, tax and spend, the party of big goverment.  I'd be less fucked off with them if the country was in a better state for all the extra money they take off me.
Quote



socialism - Noun - a political and economic theory or system in which the means of production, distribution, and exchange are owned by the community collectively, usually through the state

Collins Essential English Dictionary 2nd Edition 2006 © HarperCollins Publishers 2004, 2006

You seem to be labouring under the fairly common misapprehension that socialism equates to increased public spending. As you can see from the above, it doesn't.

And even if it did, as I thought I'd pointed out before, despite what they might say in their election material, once they're in power, they are ALL  parties of tax and spend. The last Tory government increased public spending and the average tax burden (they left power having set a record level of public borrowing and budgetary defecit)

EVERY fucking government of whatever political stripe for the last 40 years or more has by neccesity increased the average working persons tax burden in order to maintain public services in a global economic environment where the tax burden on corporations has had to be cut to the bone in order to retain jobs in the UK.

That's what happens when you start from the basis of attempting to manage capitalism. It means that regardless of a parties ideological background once in power they all behave in pretty much the same way.

So, slag of this government if you like, fuck knows I do, but don't call it socialist.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bushey Boy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 17:49:07
Quote from: "ronnie21"
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
I know what your saying mate, my english teacher made my maths teacher hold me back instead of letting me do what I was good at (numbers) fucking slut

being serious, they should introduice working methods/experience into schools
Well, BB, your english teacher didn't do much for your spelling!! :wink:


Ah ronnie, I can spell just type far too quickly.  Didn't I write a rather good email or two to your company bosses praising you but at the same time slating them? The english on that was perfect.

End of the day qualifications can help some people but I feel your career and level of success in life is more down to opportunities, your personalility and mainly luck.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Simon Pieman on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 19:20:29
Quote from: "janaage"
Taxing the higher paid just doesn't work, as the high rate tax payers can get around paying 40p in the pound.  Contributing to pensions for example.  There are ways of mitigating tax, and the rich can pay the people to find ways of doing so.


Anyone has access to incentives to avoid tax, some examples being ISAs and as you point out pension contributions.

These are just as much about incentives for people to save as providing them with a way to avoid paying tax. You don't have to be a higher rate tax payer to enjoy these kinds of reliefs.

And who's to say a higher rate taxpayer can afford to put all of their income above the higher band into a pension, just to avoid tax.

Don't forget a higher rate tax payer still has to pay NI and pension income is also taxed. Oh and a higher rate tax payer may end up spending more, thus giving the government additional VAT compared to someone who has a lower income. In turn that will generate more taxes from companies whom the (higher rate taxpaying) consumer is purchasing from.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: tans on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 19:21:33
Dave you boffin  8)

I got relatively decent grades 9 A-C and a GNVQ, but i ended up making dildos for 3 years. Beat that suckers!!


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Ralphy on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:10:02
I did shit at GCSE and then dropped out of college but I don't think i've totally fucked my life up.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: cib on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:15:16
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
That is what I am trying to say Dave , tell me what grades are relevant though at school Maths yes of course but that was my poorest grade by a mile I now work in finance so was that relevant? English what the fuck has Shakespear got to do with me getting a job?

I understand that grades are relevant to get onto certain courses that is fine but it is what your are tested on I don’t understand the relevance of


I get what you're trying to say, i answered a question today in one of my finals on whether geography matters. Clearly it matters to the students, teachers, lecturers etc whom teach/learn about the subject - a closed public for the subject. But beyond that the individual perceptions of subjects is wide ranging that does it matter if they are irrelevant? Getting really deep, does anything really matter - its up to the kid to make what they want from the world.

Someone has already said that kids get to go to college twice a week or whatever, that was the case when i was at school and from what i know it has benefitted them. On the flip side though, because they didn't excel at school is it really teachers putting them down or parents not encouraging their children to do well at school that makes them not try at school?


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: cib on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:17:32
double postage


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Bogus Dave on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:34:31
Educations been fucked up since the 60's really hasn't it. Abolishing the grammar, technical and the other kind (i forgot what it was called) in favour of the flat rate comprehensive schools we have now benefit no-one. The academically gifted are held back by those not, and those more suited to vocational type course are fecked by the curriculum. We should go back to the way it was in the 50's, but show the technichal schools a bit more respect. This happens a bit in higher education in swindon at the moment: new college does A-levels, and swindon college is more technically based. It needs to be more widespread though to have any great effect.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Reg Smeeton on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:38:36
Quote from: "cib"
Quote from: "Don Rogers Shop"
That is what I am trying to say Dave , tell me what grades are relevant though at school Maths yes of course but that was my poorest grade by a mile I now work in finance so was that relevant? English what the fuck has Shakespear got to do with me getting a job?

I understand that grades are relevant to get onto certain courses that is fine but it is what your are tested on I don’t understand the relevance of


Getting really deep, does anything really matter - its up to the kid to make what they want from the world.


 To quote Captain Beefheart.....The stars are matter. We are matter. It doesn't matter.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: Reg Smeeton on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 20:43:39
Quote from: "STFC dave"
Educations been fucked up since the 60's really hasn't it. Abolishing the grammar, technical and the other kind (i forgot what it was called) in favour of the flat rate comprehensive schools we have now benefit no-one. The academically gifted are held back by those not, and those more suited to vocational type course are fecked by the curriculum. We should go back to the way it was in the 50's, but show the technichal schools a bit more respect. This happens a bit in higher education in swindon at the moment: new college does A-levels, and swindon college is more technically based. It needs to be more widespread though to have any great effect.


 I'd argue against your proposition with some vehemence, if I could be arsed, which I can't.


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: reeves4england on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 21:18:59
Quote from: "STFC dave"
Educations been fucked up since the 60's really hasn't it. Abolishing the grammar, technical and the other kind (i forgot what it was called) in favour of the flat rate comprehensive schools we have now benefit no-one. The academically gifted are held back by those not, and those more suited to vocational type course are fecked by the curriculum. We should go back to the way it was in the 50's, but show the technichal schools a bit more respect. This happens a bit in higher education in swindon at the moment: new college does A-levels, and swindon college is more technically based. It needs to be more widespread though to have any great effect.

It had good points in terms of people doing things they are suited to, but it wasn't always successful. For instance, my mum was at the top end of the comprehensive and really struggled with school because she found it easy and too slow. I think that was the reason she couldn't stand it and quit when she started doing A-levels


Title: Pertol Prices (boycott)
Post by: ronnie21 on Tuesday, May 20, 2008, 21:47:47
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
Quote from: "ronnie21"
Quote from: "Bushey Boy"
I know what your saying mate, my english teacher made my maths teacher hold me back instead of letting me do what I was good at (numbers) fucking slut

being serious, they should introduice working methods/experience into schools
Well, BB, your english teacher didn't do much for your spelling!! :wink:


Ah ronnie, I can spell just type far too quickly.  Didn't I write a rather good email or two to your company bosses praising you but at the same time slating them? The english on that was perfect.

Yes you did mate, we'll call it a draw!! :soapy tit wank: