Thetownend.com

25% => The Reg Smeeton Match Day Action/Reaction Forum => Topic started by: adje on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 11:27:21



Title: Ratings
Post by: adje on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 11:27:21
Evans 6-didn't have much of a chance with either goal,handling was good
Gurney 2-absolute cack as usual,wherever he plays.This man is not a footballer in any sense of the word
O'Hanlon 3-seems to be in a permanent state of confusion lately
Smith 3-Iffy should have taken him off straight after the second goal
Nicholas 3-Confidence lokks shot-couple of decent forays into the Tranmere half
Pook5-We were that bad,Pook was our best midfielder-by a long way.Kept posession better than anyone else,unlucky not to score,great save by the Estonian,and actually won a few tackles.
Migz 3-The most alarming deterioration of any Town player Ive ever seen.This guy has seemingly totally lost it.Shame
Brown 4-intermittently dangerous-much improved in second half
Peacock 3-I dont buy all this"he's the only one that tries"bollocks.He pulls out of tackles,wins a very small percentage of headers for a "big man"and,honestly,NEVER looks like scoring
Cureton 6-now he DOES look hungry.lovely finish
Benjamin 2-CHRIST!That must go down as one of the worst centre forward displays of all time-nowhere near the ball at any time.Reminded me of the days when we used to get players like McCammon,Shane Bradley and Kyle Lightbourne on loan.Hopeless!
Shakes 5-Tend to think we'd have played a lot better if  he'd started.At least we livened up when he came on.Few decent runs,won us a few corners and throws.
Jarrett 1-Iffy should have left Browny on the wing and brought on Whalley imo.


Title: Ratings
Post by: DMR on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 11:48:43
Agree with most of that except Pook was gash and Evans should have kept number 2 out.


Title: Ratings
Post by: magicroundabout on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 11:56:01
not sure about Peacock.
I thought he was chasing everything for little or no reward.

evans for the second goal was unlucky. defence let him down


Title: Ratings
Post by: my-velocity on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 15:31:59
Iffy has made his first mistake as a manager, fielding a non compatible squad and getting his formation completely wrong. You all saw Tranmere had a lot of pacey players (number 11 being the one who ran all the way from his end of the pitch to the other without getting tackled and it reulting in a goal), so we should have started Shakes and Brown on the wings.

It's far to early to call for iffys head, but please oh please don't field a team like that again.


Title: Ratings
Post by: STFCere on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 15:37:34
adje, great review! very funny, harshest match review ive ever seen..great stuff, were we worse than forest away? i went to that and we were truely shocking, are you telling me we were worse last night !? :shock:  :shock:  :shock:


Title: Ratings
Post by: stfc11 on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 16:54:23
i didn't think Gurney did all that badly, better in defence than midfield


Title: Ratings
Post by: DiV on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 17:19:08
I agree totally with you adje....


Title: Ratings
Post by: Tails on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 18:57:05
Peacock never looks like scoring..Apart from the header he had saved early on? Hitting the bar against Forest? Peacock works his fucking arse off.


Title: Ratings
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 18:58:52
i wont do a ratings thing! dont need to really. Evans, Curo, Peacock - 6

everyone else - 0 simple as that! ok that was a ratings thing but still!


Title: Ratings
Post by: reeves4england on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 19:07:03
Bit harsh Rich

Evans 6 - Made some good saves, no chance with either goal

Smith 4 - Caught out too often
Gurns 3 - What planet was the guy on?!
O'Hanlon 4 - Looked abit lost with no Ifil covering him, and made silly mistakes
Nicholas 4 - Let his man get away too often but his throws would keep him his place for me

Migs 3 - Poor. That is all I can say
Brown - 3 Not a central midfielder
Pook 5 - Didn't stand out as good or bad

Benjamin 3 - Slow, the overhead kick saved him from a 2
Peacock 4 - Ran everywhere but had little to do with poor service for the majority of the game
Cureton 6 - Again ran everywhere and never stopped, good goal, looked hungry

Shakes 6 - Made the difference when he came on. Was a spark and won us possession and created chances. The game was crying out for wingers and changing the formation at half-time made a huge difference. 4-4-2 all the way Iffy


Title: Ratings
Post by: adje on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 22:00:33
Quote from: "Tails"
Peacock never looks like scoring..Apart from the header he had saved early on? Hitting the bar against Forest? Peacock works his fucking arse off.



That miss against Forest?You're using that as a positive?Fucking hell,my mother could have put that away


Title: Ratings
Post by: Tails on Wednesday, March 8, 2006, 23:13:12
Why don't we put her upfront then?


Title: Ratings
Post by: McLovin on Thursday, March 9, 2006, 09:04:11
R4E, you'd keep someone in a footy team because he has long throws?! How many goals have we scored from the aforementioned long throws? Strange...