ratings v swans

[DMR]

evans- better kicking, 2 top stops to keep the score down and no chance with goals- 7 motm

smith- bit of a cunt. play on next time its still in son, better crosses though- 4

o'hanlon- strong but faded badly i thought, fouls someone everytime he gets forawrd- 5

nicho- didn't realise the man was playing not sure whether thats good or bad- 5

brown- thought he did quite well actually works hard and gets stuck in too- 7

dia- total let down can't pass for shit- 2

shakes- still can't control anything but our only consistent outlet, good goal anticipation - 6

mcphee- anonymous at best, ace throws though- 3

peacock- irrelevant


lukas- did ok but no service

[stfc_carver]

bit harsh on dia, thort he was worth a 5-6 at least

[STFC Village]

dia- total let down can't pass for shit- 2

Agree with all, except that.

[DMR]

It would seem I forgot Whalley and CCP. Says it all really.

[sonicyouth]

dia- total let down can't pass for shit- 2

are you insane? he was the only player who gave a toss tonight. admittedly he can't shoot or cross and some of his passes went astray, but i'd blame other peoples lack of movement as much as him for that.

thought brown was rubbish as well.

were we playing 442 or 352? i couldnt work it out all night

[DMR]

thought dia was at fault for the equaliser too tbh

im not disputing he cares he's just a bit naff. "can't shoot or cross and some of his passes went astray" not your ideal playmaker then is it?

[sonicyouth]

i didn't realise he was a playmaker and i don't really think we're a team who can afford the luxury of one either

as far as i'm concerned his job is to run around a lot, tackle the opposition, win the ball and make simple passes. which he does pretty effectively.

[Tails]

brown and evans did well I thought.
Peacock was good before he went off.
Lukas did OK considering he was man handled everytime he touched the ball.