Thetownend.com

25% => The Reg Smeeton Match Day Action/Reaction Forum => Topic started by: blinkpip on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 19:19:51



Title: Whalley
Post by: blinkpip on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 19:19:51
Was excellent today. My MOTM.  8)

Iffy should've played him a long time ago.  Jenkins also had a good game, untill he got injured.


Title: Whalley
Post by: Sade on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 19:21:10
I totally agree Blinkers. He was brilliant.


Title: Whalley
Post by: Johno on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 19:26:08
the only person i was annoyed with was shakes when he came on. Whole team played well and should have got all 3 points.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 19:47:31
Whalley was fucking excellent out there today, he was controled and calm on the ball, only got caught in posession once and I only remember two passes of his that didnt go to a red shirt.

He seemed a class above anything else on that pitch today, he pulled the strings all our moves went through him.

He was well over due a game


Title: Whalley
Post by: McLovin on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 20:15:10
He'll be dropped next week, just like after the Vale game. Was excellent today (by our standards)


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 20:16:39
Quote from: "Dave Blackcurrant"
He'll be dropped next week, just like after the Vale game. Was excellent today (by our standards)


Missed that game!

Certainly doesnt deserve to be dropped at all....best player on the park by a long way


Title: Whalley
Post by: Simon Pieman on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 20:16:57
Hopefully he will not be dropped then. I don't think he was doing too well in the reserves which is why he hadn't been used. But then nobody's been doing well of late from what I hear...


Title: Whalley
Post by: reeves4england on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 20:42:33
Came into the team and did well. Bossed the centre of the park. THAT is why Kingy got him in


Title: Whalley
Post by: my-velocity on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 21:31:29
I keep saying Whalley should get a chance, he did and deserves MOTM no doubt.

Quality Player


Title: Whalley
Post by: Bogus Dave on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 21:49:56
whalley was by far and away the best player on the pitch. annoyed by the bloke behind me who said he was shit cos he always passed backwards. it ent all about blood and thunder m8.


Title: Whalley
Post by: stfc11 on Saturday, March 11, 2006, 22:16:17
So glad he got his chance, and equally glad he took it and performed so well, hope he starts next saturday!


Title: Whalley
Post by: Iffy's Onion Bhaji on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 13:07:14
its taken him this long but FINALLY he actually plays well!  :Ride On Fatbury's Lovestick:


Title: Whalley
Post by: flammableBen on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 13:09:23
I think he should be dropped. Two consecutive good games might be a bit of an ask.


Title: Whalley
Post by: reeves4england on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 14:08:23
He did well and maybe he has regained fitness or something because I can see no other reason why he would have ben out of the team so long and then just get thrown in.
He passed well, tackled well and held the ball up


Title: Whalley
Post by: Johno on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 14:10:48
in the new of the world thing, swindon players got 5's and 6's. who the hell writes that thing i dunno. aaron davies for them got 8.... :-))( Evans got 4 somehow?

we should have had at least all 7's and yeovil have got 5 and 6's like they should.


Title: Whalley
Post by: reeves4england on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 14:13:24
Evans 6 (Made some mistakes lets be honest)
Nicho 6
Gurns 7
Seano 6
Jenks 6
Smith 7
Whalley 8
Pook 6
Brown 7
Curo 6
Peacock 6

Migs 5
Shakes 2 (Was that the real Ricky Shakes?!)


Title: Whalley
Post by: Spencer_White on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 14:17:40
Hats off. He done good.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DMR on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 14:41:21
Quote from: "DV85"
Whalley was fucking excellent out there today, he was controled and calm on the ball, only got caught in posession once and I only remember two passes of his that didnt go to a red shirt.

He seemed a class above anything else on that pitch today, he pulled the strings all our moves went through him.

He was well over due a game


Word, very impressed.


Title: Whalley
Post by: Tails on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:04:24
Quote from: "dave_m_russell"
Quote from: "DV85"
Whalley was fucking excellent out there today, he was controled and calm on the ball, only got caught in posession once and I only remember two passes of his that didnt go to a red shirt.

He seemed a class above anything else on that pitch today, he pulled the strings all our moves went through him.

He was well over due a game


Word, very impressed.


With Whalleys performance or the fact DV said something positive?


Title: Whalley
Post by: sonicyouth on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:14:52
i missed yesterday's game, obviously, but i've seen whalley a number of times and have never been particularly impressed with him, bar one good performance at port vale - after which he shouldn't have been dropped - but provided he continues to play well he'll be an extra option in midfield and possibly an almost direct replacement for stef, who has been poor lately.

i assumed there was other circumstances for him being a forgotten man in midfield, if spencer's right about him then it'd certainly make sense. i'm sure i recall reading that he's not the sort of player to get stuck in when the going gets tough when he joined.

i noticed he's only signed a 2 year deal as well, i was sure it was 3 but he turned down 3 at grimsby to sign for 2 here.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:24:36
Quote from: "Tails"
Quote from: "dave_m_russell"
Quote from: "DV85"
Whalley was fucking excellent out there today, he was controled and calm on the ball, only got caught in posession once and I only remember two passes of his that didnt go to a red shirt.

He seemed a class above anything else on that pitch today, he pulled the strings all our moves went through him.

He was well over due a game


Word, very impressed.


With Whalleys performance or the fact DV said something positive?


 :twisted:

It was a good performance, and I still wonder why hasnt been in the team for ages....


Title: Whalley
Post by: sonicyouth on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:28:47
on the basis of what spencer suggested about him, i wouldn't select him unless absolutely neccesary. i imagine iffy isn't the type to put up with that sort of attitude either.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:37:49
Quote from: "sonicyouth"
on the basis of what spencer suggested about him, i wouldn't select him unless absolutely neccesary. i imagine iffy isn't the type to put up with that sort of attitude either.


but if he is better than Miglioranzi, Gurney, Smith, CCP & Pook then surely you put him in?

You have to remember that Whalley has played at the top level, infact off the top of my head he is the only one in our squad who has played at the highest level. There is a reason why he made it that far.


Title: Whalley
Post by: sonicyouth on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:48:15
he's never played at the top level has he? i thought he left bradford the season they went up.

of our current squad, i think only benjamin has played in the premiership.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 15:58:31
Quote from: "sonicyouth"
he's never played at the top level has he? i thought he left bradford the season they went up.

of our current squad, i think only benjamin has played in the premiership.


I thought he did play for them in the Premiership??

How Benjamin got into the Premiership, god only knows.....


Title: Whalley
Post by: DMR on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 16:16:31
Quote from: "sonicyouth"
on the basis of what spencer suggested about him, i wouldn't select him unless absolutely neccesary. i imagine iffy isn't the type to put up with that sort of attitude either.


rubbish, that's only hearsay anyway isn't it.

you pick the right man for the job and whalley proved he's got the quality yesterday and thus stays in the team, unless you're a prat or a meddler. unfortunately, iffy meddles too much.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DMR on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 16:45:16
"He's applied himself well and he's been a top, top proffessional throughout a tough time" said Iffy.

End of discussion.


Title: Whalley
Post by: Reeves for King on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 18:53:15
Yeah, he wa really good today.

Sean played better today with Jenks I thought.


Title: Whalley
Post by: sonicyouth on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 19:03:50
Quote from: "dave_m_russell"
Quote from: "sonicyouth"
on the basis of what spencer suggested about him, i wouldn't select him unless absolutely neccesary. i imagine iffy isn't the type to put up with that sort of attitude either.


rubbish, that's only hearsay anyway isn't it.

you pick the right man for the job and whalley proved he's got the quality yesterday and thus stays in the team, unless you're a prat or a meddler. unfortunately, iffy meddles too much.


hearsay it maybe, but neither of us knows if it's true or not. personally i think it's a fairly logical explanation given the fact he's been left out for so long.

the right man for the job usually needs the right attitude and if whalley was the right man for the job yesterday then perhaps it disproves what i've suggested.

as for iffy being a meddler, fair point to an extent but you can hardly play the same eleven after a 3-2 capitulation, a 7-1 humiliation and a poor 2-1 loss.


Title: Whalley
Post by: STFC Village on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 19:09:30
Ace! You liked my poem then? 8)


Title: Whalley
Post by: sonicyouth on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 19:15:24
it was superb 8) thank you


Title: Whalley
Post by: Tails on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 19:39:00
Sonic what did Spence say about Whalley? I'm a bit lost...


Title: Whalley
Post by: STFC Village on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 19:44:05
Tails.....

http://thetownend.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=10408


Title: Re: Whalley
Post by: Bedford Red on Sunday, March 12, 2006, 20:08:28
Quote from: "blinkpip"
Was excellent today. My MOTM.  8)

Iffy should've played him a long time ago.  Jenkins also had a good game, untill he got injured.


 :nod:


Title: Whalley
Post by: red macca on Monday, March 13, 2006, 11:15:22
if i was looking for a new club i would play well aswell


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Monday, March 13, 2006, 12:49:58
Quote from: "red macca"
if i was looking for a new club i would play well aswell


so why have all our other players been rubbish recently, you cant tell me they all want to stay at Swindon?


Title: Whalley
Post by: red macca on Monday, March 13, 2006, 16:02:55
maybe they are not good enough to play anywhere else thought of that???


Title: Whalley
Post by: Leggett on Monday, March 13, 2006, 16:15:32
you dont half spout some shit red macca...


Title: Whalley
Post by: red macca on Monday, March 13, 2006, 16:27:23
why is that then coz i dont agree with you fuck off.if they were good enough we would not be in the shit we are in would we.whalley is paying up his contract soon obviously needs to be in the shop window.i got no problem with that if it helps the cause but dont go kidding yourself thinking these players are better than they actually are the table suggests otherwise so maybe you could stop sprouting shit for once


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Monday, March 13, 2006, 20:13:01
Quote from: "red macca"
why is that then coz i dont agree with you fuck off.if they were good enough we would not be in the shit we are in would we.whalley is paying up his contract soon obviously needs to be in the shop window.i got no problem with that if it helps the cause but dont go kidding yourself thinking these players are better than they actually are the table suggests otherwise so maybe you could stop sprouting shit for once


Whalley has another year left on his contract?


Title: Whalley
Post by: Leggett on Monday, March 13, 2006, 20:25:35
sprouting shit?



or maybe spouting shit?



who knows.



infact, who fucking cares? not me...


Title: Whalley
Post by: red macca on Tuesday, March 14, 2006, 14:27:32
Quote from: "DV85"
Quote from: "red macca"
why is that then coz i dont agree with you fuck off.if they were good enough we would not be in the shit we are in would we.whalley is paying up his contract soon obviously needs to be in the shop window.i got no problem with that if it helps the cause but dont go kidding yourself thinking these players are better than they actually are the table suggests otherwise so maybe you could stop sprouting shit for once


Whalley has another year left on his contract?
so did thorpe??leggett if you dont care keep your opinions to yourself.


Title: Whalley
Post by: DiV on Tuesday, March 14, 2006, 17:44:10
Quote from: "red macca"
Quote from: "DV85"
Quote from: "red macca"
why is that then coz i dont agree with you fuck off.if they were good enough we would not be in the shit we are in would we.whalley is paying up his contract soon obviously needs to be in the shop window.i got no problem with that if it helps the cause but dont go kidding yourself thinking these players are better than they actually are the table suggests otherwise so maybe you could stop sprouting shit for once


Whalley has another year left on his contract?
so did thorpe??leggett if you dont care keep your opinions to yourself.


But Thorpe clearly wanted to leave and was thus putting in no effort in the few games he played....a man clearly in a place he didnt want to be.


Title: Whalley
Post by: Bogus Dave on Tuesday, March 14, 2006, 18:29:17
thorpe was a cunt. cureton and whally had a tough start but have came back well, and have put in the effort. thorpe couldnt be assed and it showed. he may be a better striker than some of our current strikers (holgate benjamin roberts??)  but they try. thorpe thought he was coming here for an easy ride, but when he found out it would be tough, he just fukedabout. im glad he pissed off.

rant over :evil:


Title: Whalley
Post by: Tails on Tuesday, March 14, 2006, 18:51:24
I bet he'll score past us next week  :evil: