There's no decision to make, it has to be Collingwood.
He's a great all round cricketer with a good cricket brain.
Cook's too young and doesn't have enough experience, fuck 'start getting some experience' we want a captain who'll win us games now, not in 5 years time.
I disagree. Cook has a great cricketing brain. He doesnt have Collingwoods experience but he still has plenty. Colly is a great cricketer but that doesnt make a great captain. He has to bat, bowl and as probably our best fielder he has enough to think about; being captain as well i fear could be too much.
I think Cook would win us games now, not just in 5 years time, but the main aim is surely to rebuild a new one day squad for the next world cup. We cant change things over night, it takes time and a complete change of regime and tactics.
I think Colly will get the job though and i hope he does a good job. We have spent a lot of time and work over the past 4 years getting the test team sorted and we are now 2nd best in the world. Its time to get the one day team sorted and up to that level.
