Part of his idea is that he wants to even the playing field slightly across the top two divisions by spreading the huge scads of money that the PL get across PL 1 & 2.
I really don't see the distribution of TV money being a problem as there is more money than ever being paid for TV rights for the Football League and some of the Premier League money does filter down (through promotion and relegation, transfer fees etc).
The real problem is that far too many clubs spend money they don't have - through incompetence, through trying to compete with the big clubs and through trying to win promotion. Even worse is that everyone seems to accept massive losses at clubs without batting an eyelid.
Is it really acceptable for a club like Swindon to lose £2m a season?
If you stop clubs from spending money they don't have, wages and transfer fees will fall in to line with what clubs can actually afford. When the Football League clubs have sorted their act out with their finances, I reckon it would put them in a far stronger position to go cap in hand to the Premier League if necessary.
As regards Gartside's proposal; Celtic and Rangers will never play in the English league pyramid and promotion and relegation are here to stay. In short, he's got fuck all chance of getting the support he needs. Even if we were going to be one of the lucky clubs locked in to the Premier League and still say over my dead body and I'm pretty sure 99.99% of other fans would say the same.